90g + ~10g Sump + ~10g Fuge — Need new Skimmer

ThaChad

New member
Hey All,

I Have a 90g Main Display, with a ~20g Sump/Fuge split.

My SWC Xtreme 160 Co e Skimmer pump took a dump after 10 years. Since they are no longer in business and I can’t seem to find a definitive direct replacement pump…

I am in the market for a new Skimmer!

I really don’t want to spend over $300.

Unlike 10+ years ago when there were inly a few choices and of those few 1/2 of them were actually any good. Today there are seemingly 100’s of choices..

in a google search, I came across this one: https://fishtankusa.com/products/simplicity-120dc-in-sump-protein-skimmer?currency=USD

Which has a DC motor, Thought it seemed like a good price and value, but beyond that, I know nothing about it?

Has any one tried this model? Input? Other suggestions?

Smaller is better as I have limited room. The SWC Xtreme 160 was maxed out for headroom and size.

Thanks All!

-ThaChad
 

mellotang

Premium Member
I’ve read good reviews about simplicity skimmer

no first hand experience though

tunze hydrofoamer produces the best foam
of any skimmer I’ve used
 

mellotang

Premium Member
Tunze has a unique bio load calculation

if your running SPS then you reduce the recommended volume by 70%

that’s a good skimmer for tank volume around 80-100 gallon
 

kharmaguru

Premium Member
If a DC pump is a requisite, I doubt you'll beat that Simplicity price. If DC doesn't matter, lots of people like these Bubble magus Curve 5 skimmers. A little bigger base than the simplicity but same height, a few bucks cheaper.

https://https://www.aquacave.com/bubble-magus-5ex-extreme-curve-protein-skimmer.html

Personally I use the smaller brother of yours that died - SWC 120 - but since it uses the common Atman PH1100 pump, I should be able to keep it going forever. I love it.
 
Top