Aaaarrrggghhh WTH!! mourning this morning

becon776

New member
O.k. I knew it was too good to be true.. Everything was perfect, imagine that.. Things were working out and I was like WOW this is too good to be true no algae... perfect water tests... fish eating fine... perfect.
HAH my tank stock = a small yellow tang, a royal gramma, two percs (from my old 20), a mandarin that loved mysyid, and a yellow watchman goby. A array of snails, purple tuxedo urchin, and a cleaner shrimp.

Of course I noticed some ick on the YT nothing too bad and he was being cleaned regularly by the shrimp. All of the sudden the royal gramma dies and the friggin hermits dragged him into a crevice at the bottom of the rockwork... I was like ok either destroy the rock stack for a little gramma or let things go and let the hermits have dinner.. I chose the latter within hours the mandaring dies, then shortly after the yellow tank kicks and then the clownfish. now the yellow watchman goby (who was the last fish added) has got the tank to himself) with ZERO signs of ick or anything else. Tank water checks out perfectly! Corals are all doing better than good including the couple sps pieces that I've got. Damn it!
I want to let the tank s just sit with corals so that the ick can run it's cycle and I'll be able to start fresh... but that darn watchman will never be caught and he could be carrying it and not showing it. Also I get very nervous not having a herbivore fish in the tank for too long. I don't even want to deal with a waft of PITA hair algae as I still have nightmares of that from my old 125 and I have had excellent luck with that so far.
I decided to do a healthy water change 20 gallons even though the water checks out perfect.
Jeez what's a guy to do?
 
Sorry to hear about the lost fish.

Looking back over your posts, you just filled the tank with water around the 25th of February, right? That is a lot of fish to put in in one month.

Slow down a little. Try and get the watchman out and let the tank stay clear of fish for 6 weeks. And then start slowly...and QT your new arrivals.
 
Also post the exact results of testing for ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, ph, temp, calcium, alk, etc... What you consider perfect, may not be.

Carrie
 
Ca = just shy of 500
alk =
NH4 = 0
nitrate = 2 ppm
nitirite = 0
pH = 8.2
PO4 = <1ppm
temp 78 with a possible 1-2 degree shift from halides
halides on for 8 and actinics 10

Although I just put water in it would have been the equivalent of doing a 100% water change. almost all the rock came from a jameed crammed 20 gall which has been op for almost 1.5 years. It was out of the water <5 min. I got NO cycle at all or not at least one that registered. Tiny diatom bloom. Thats it.

If it's a water problem then I would expect that it would be with heavy metals.... maybe phosban (Al+)... but that has only been in for 2 weeks, and wouldn't the corals be affected? The Acro looks fantastic.

damn... you know last night I had a dream that there was a mantis shrimp in my tank and it killed all me fish... weird.
 
I'd get the nitrate down to 0 by doing water changes. Raise temp to 79-82 and lower calcium to 450. Good luck.
 
yeah they are perfect. know what.. I'm gonna change out that damn phosban right now... it's tweaking me out. If my water checks out o.k. I'm gonna look into blue neon gobies... I think I added too many fish in too short of time and now that I think about it I prolly wasn't feeding nearly as well as I should have been (it's the post traumatic stress disorder from hair algae in the past, see gallery and you'll see what I mean) so I fed VERY sparingly.
Corals are doin amazing... in fact, my acro is now turning from a brown to a neon green.. very cool under the actinics
 
Back
Top