John Zillmer
Member
before more comments added i would like to say the tank size doesnt mean anything, its all the liverock amount. most people say 50lbs is enough.
somone can have a 500gallon with just 60lbs of liverock...
Sadly, this is a case of someone asking about the requirements needed for keeping a specific fish healthy and are told what they can provide isn't sufficient. The person then disregards everyone's advice and buys the fish anyway.
Meh...we tried. It just really bothers me. Why ask for advice at all then?
So far as I can tell, the OP is simply disputing the advice given, and doing so on the basis of other information (correct or not) that is relevant to the issue. I don't see the OP buying any fish, Sugar Magnolia, so your disdainful comments are out of line. Please don't contribute to the 'toe the line, or we'll bash you' mentality that crops up around here from time to time, eh?