I would not expect a Laser thermometer to be that accurate measuring the temperature of liquids. The glass thermometer would need to be calibrated to a NIST standard or it to can be off.
In either case, shy of getting a rather prices NIST temperature standard 1-2 F is will not affect tanks; stability is most important. That said there is a thread from way back that included some links to purchase NIST standard thermometers for calibration; the glass ones start around $50, the electronic ones around > $150 (if I remember correctly).