Pbrown3701
New member
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11700399#post11700399 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Horace
I will say that it does/did work just fine in my system as well. I very very rarely ever have to adjust one or the others independently. I agree they may not get used EXACTLY the same, but its very very close, and it takes several weeks if not several months for the imbalance to become an issue.
As for your supersaturation theory, yes, you are correct. But the levels your talking about hardly are super saturated. A level of 430ppm Ca is a far cry from super saturated. Ive run my Ca up over 500ppm and still not had any of the frosting you are talking about. The only time ive ever seen frosting is when I accidentally dosed a full gallon of each part in about 5 mins due to a siphon. This turned the tank pure white...the water was like milk. At that point there was major precip because of the high levels of saturation and sky high PH. If you have frosting, then you must be running your PH sky high.....I never even saw frosting when I had my PH at about 8.6 while dosing kalk.
Yikes :lol: That is a whole 'nother story all together.
No, when I say "frosting" i mean just the glass and pumps etc get coated with a thin layer of calcium carbonate. I notice this when I try to run my levels any higher than I do (that is how I settled in on my current levels). This could be due to my Magnesium levels also as Mg helps maintain a supersaturated level of Ca and CO3. If your Mg levels are low, then you will not be able to keep your cal and alk levels up. In fact, without Mg, the levels of Cal and Alk in our systems are actually supersaturated. If there was no Mg, then it would precipitate out a lot sooner. ANd, I don't test for Mg as I have not found a good test kit for it. I run pH of 8.2
Either way - all of this is getting off topic of the thread and that is a simple cheap dual dosing pump. It's not perfect, but compared to manual dosing or dosing via some kind of gravity system...It is far superior (IMO).
Last edited: