Is my goby sick?

malx

Active member
He has a white spot under his dorsal fin where he's lost color. Not the kind if spot you see with Ich. Here's a picture:
7e50726a4e8d96bd27f896e308ab4cd4.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
My guess is Lympho also. Feeding good quality food and feedin 2x per day usually helps keep many diseases down. Also don't forger good stable water parameters too.
 
Good tips. I've googled and read and I agree it's probably this. I only feed my tank 3x a week so there is a good shot he's not getting enough food. I will increase feedings this week to 2x daily and see how that affects my nutrients. My water quality is good. Just tested today. Ammonia 0, Nitrite 0.001ppm, Nitrate 1pm, Phosphate 0.02ppm. I'm doing SPS so I am trying to keep my nutrients low. With that said, I only have test frags in there now and they are doing OK.

Here's what I am feeding tomorrow.

PE Mysis Shrimp fortified with Phyto.
BRS Reef Chili.

Tomorrow night I'll just do Mysid and some Pellets from Sustainable Aquatics's hatchery diet and do that for the rest of the week then go back to PE, Phyto and Reef Chili on Friday.

I'll keep everyone posted.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
You can't starve your live critters for the sake of water quality. You need to learn how to export those nutrients.

I've got a 40b with a 20 gal sump and have 9 fish in it. Rarely are my nitrates over 10 and I do an every two week 20% water change. I feed twice a day and sometimes when I'm around a third time. Morning and night are frozen mysis or a frozen mix, during mid day is NLS pellets. My fish are fat and happy and so are my mix of corals. LPS, SPS and leathers. I also feed my corals 3x a week a mix of coral foods.

Cherub angel
McCosker's wrasse
Pair Mocha Clowns
Midas Blenny
Matted Filefish
Scooter blenny
Royal Gramma

You don't want 0 nitrates and 0 phosphates. You want to target 5 nitrates and 0.025 phosphates. Having both 0 will starve your SPS unless you're doing direct feedin daily to them.
Yellow Candy Hogfish
 
Last edited:
Good tips. I've googled and read and I agree it's probably this. I only feed my tank 3x a week so there is a good shot he's not getting enough food. I will increase feedings this week to 2x daily and see how that affects my nutrients. My water quality is good. Just tested today. Ammonia 0, Nitrite 0.001ppm, Nitrate 1pm, Phosphate 0.02ppm. I'm doing SPS so I am trying to keep my nutrients low. With that said, I only have test frags in there now and they are doing OK.

Here's what I am feeding tomorrow.

PE Mysis Shrimp fortified with Phyto.
BRS Reef Chili.

Tomorrow night I'll just do Mysid and some Pellets from Sustainable Aquatics's hatchery diet and do that for the rest of the week then go back to PE, Phyto and Reef Chili on Friday.

I'll keep everyone posted.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

what test kit are you testing with .001ppm nitrites and 1pm nitrates. thats some very precise numbers, too precise imo
also dont go crazy testing nitrites you should never have them in a weel established reef. and as far as nitrates and phosphates i normally dont test them or f i do maybe once a month. if your corals look good and you dont have alot or any algae imo there is no reason to test for them. .

also you can train your goby to eat right out of a turkey baster . my fish eat too fast for my goby, so i have to feed him like a baby :)
 
what test kit are you testing with .001ppm nitrites and 1pm nitrates. thats some very precise numbers, too precise imo

also you can train your goby to eat right out of a turkey baster . my fish eat too fast for my goby, so i have to feed him like a baby :)

Mine eats out of a baster. I have Hannah Ultra Low Range checkers for Nitrite and NYOS for Nitrate. I trust them.
 
Mine eats out of a baster. I have Hannah Ultra Low Range checkers for Nitrite and NYOS for Nitrate. I trust them.

oh i wasnt saying they are wrong, just saying your being to cautious about your number, dont starve your fish because your afraid to over feed.
 
oh i wasnt saying they are wrong, just saying your being to cautious about your number, dont starve your fish because your afraid to over feed.



True. You live and you learn. Let's see where we are at in a week :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
yes i been there, my first tak many years ago i tested everything every day. you will learn what works for you. just dont do anything drastic, slow changes are better than fast. unless everything is dying anyway.
 
yes i been there, my first tak many years ago i tested everything every day. you will learn what works for you. just dont do anything drastic, slow changes are better than fast. unless everything is dying anyway.



Good point. Just fed them again :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
So update. Goby has same spots. No new spots have appeared and current ones haven't gotten any worse. He attacks the turkey feeder when I go to target feed him. Been feeding 2x day. Guess that's a good sign that he's active and eating.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Status update here. Been feeding the guy twice a day and his white spot seems to be filing back in with color after two weeks. He eats like a pig. That's good news :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Excellent! Glad to hear that :thumbsup:

I forgot to mention earlier in this thread that since your tank is cycled you no longer need to test for ammonia or nitrites, UNLESS there is a problem. Once a tank is cycled they are a non issue.

What is important now are

Nitrates
Phosphates
Ca
Mg
Kh
AND of course sg
 
Excellent! Glad to hear that :thumbsup:

I forgot to mention earlier in this thread that since your tank is cycled you no longer need to test for ammonia or nitrites, UNLESS there is a problem. Once a tank is cycled they are a non issue.

What is important now are

Nitrates
Phosphates
Ca
Mg
Kh
AND of course sg



Yeah I know but I do it anyway as part of my weekly routine because I have the kits and they will expire anyways if I don't use them. I might be wasting my time but peace of mind is always nice!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top