Killing Mushroom corals?

[Jadams]

Has anyone ever had to intentionally kill mushroom corals? If so, how did you do it? Can I simply "cut" them off the LR they are attached too?

The reason I'm looking to do this is there are 4 purple mushrooms in a place I want to now add an SPS coral. And unforunatly, they are attached to a vary large peice of base rock that can not be removed from the tank.

Thanks for the help!

 

[Sk8r]

Sell the rock. Revise the rock structure. It's SOOOO much easier.
Cut, they will reproduce. Smashed, they will reproduce even faster.
i've heard that a trigger may eat them---but its appetite isn't limited to shrooms.

 

[xtm]

I just replied to a similar topic on the Reef Discussion forum.. can't remember if you started that thread or not. Anyways... fluke tab (tiny amount) will pretty much KILL them. Be advised that it will also kill just about every softies in your tank minus aptasias.

 

[Jadams]

fluke tab?? What is this? Where do I get it?

 

[TrojanScott]

try Joe's Juice. I've actually heard it works better on mushrooms than aiptasia!

 

[Jadams]

I do have some Joe's Juice at home right now. Has anyone else tried this before?

 

[euphoricgear]

scrape off the bottom part of the stalk and give to me

 

[Jadams]

euphoricgear - If you want them, your more then welcome to them. Let me know if you want to make the trip down to Huntington Beach for them...

 

[Dancing4raiin]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12896046#post12896046 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by xtm
I just replied to a similar topic on the Reef Discussion forum.. can't remember if you started that thread or not. Anyways... fluke tab (tiny amount) will pretty much KILL them. Be advised that it will also kill just about every softies in your tank minus aptasias.

:lol: Of course nothing kills aptasias.

 

[InTr4nceWeTrust]

Set fire to them....really...

I remember another thread on another forum about a guy trying to get rid of the shrooms on this rock. They bury themselves pretty deep into the rock.

 

[euphoricgear]

oh man thought hb was closer to redondo. i'll think about it. going to carson sat night

 

[Jadams]

sounds good. Let me know.

 

[glaudds]

Re: Killing Mushroom corals?

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12895998#post12895998 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Jadams
Can I simply "cut" them off the LR they are attached too?

IME, mushrooms are difficult to "kill." Even if you can, I'd be concerned with all the dead mushroom tissue impacting your water quality.

I've taken an old screwdriver and sharpened the edge like a chisel. Then using the screwdriver to chisel out mushroom including a small slice of LR attached to the mushroom base. This assures you get all the mushroom, because there is a good chance another will regenerate if you leave any behind.

Do this outside of the tank over a bucket of water if possible..makes it much easier than doing in the tank.

Then you can take the fragments and super glue them to larger pieces of rubble rock to sell or trade.

Other options that I have used with mixed success is to shade the mushrooms or blow them with a power head. This will sometimes cause the mushroom to loosen it's grip to the rock, making it easier to peel off.

Here's an old picture of my tank with my mushroom plague...

 

[Jadams]

glaudds - WOW Mushroom plaque is right!!!! I just have a few I want to get rid of, you have like 1,000...hahaha

Thanks for the input!

 

[euphoricgear]

i think mushrooms are nice! i started getting into saltwater cause of mushrooms

 

[newnanoboy]

mushrooms can't be killed!

 

[roxy25]

I would want them also if you where closer ......

 

[tangreefkeeper]

mushroom plague

mushroom plague

if you still want to get rid of some of your out of control mushrooms im totally interested in coming down and getting some from you

 

[phreeflow]

I agree with Glaudds...just chip a small piece of rock where the mushroom is attached. I've used wire cutters and was able to easily clip off little pieces of live rock with shrooms on them. Was easy. Will be especially easy for you since you only have 4 pieces.

 

[Jadams]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=12924513#post12924513 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by phreeflow
I agree with Glaudds...just chip a small piece of rock where the mushroom is attached. I've used wire cutters and was able to easily clip off little pieces of live rock with shrooms on them. Was easy. Will be especially easy for you since you only have 4 pieces.

That's what im gonna try this weekend. They're in a very easy spot to get too so im sure it will work great. Thanks!!!!