As long as you are able to calibrate, and the numbers dont drift too much over a short period of time, the probe is good. I have a probe that is 2 years old on a controller, it calibrates the same as a 6 month old probe on a meter I have. I only calibrate every 2-3 mos., this has worked well for me.
Probes must be kept wet. As long as the unused probe has been stored correctly it should be good.