Will coral banded shrimp and peppermint shrimp play nice?

[Mark9]

I am going move everything from my pico tank (2.5 gallons) to 2 other tanks.
I want to put the peppermint shrimp in a tank that already has a coral banded shrimp in it.
Will they get along?
it's an 8 gallon biocube with the only other inhabitant a yellowtail damsel.

the pico

the biocube

 

[Calappidae]

I wouldn't trust a CBS with a peppermint in a 125 let alone an 8g.

 

[acabgd]

I wouldn't trust a CBS with a peppermint in a 125 let alone an 8g.

I've had them in a 60g and they went along fine - although on opposite sides of the tank. Yet, in an 8g... I wouldn't count on it.

 

[fisheater]

We found our peppermints cut in half near the CBS den this morning. They were in a 90g. So my guess is that they are not going to live together.

 

[pelfiredc]

Definitely not..IMO...had em wipe anything they could get near out ...all other inverts

 

[Themilkman248]

mines been a model citizen irritates corals by stealing their food never seen it eat my peppermints but I barely see them anyway but there still there

 

[arnoldrew]

I don't think I would trust it in that small of a tank. I've got 3 peps and a CBS in a 90 gallon and haven't had any issues. The peps stay as far away from the CBS as they can.

 

[erndog1001]

I would say don't do it. I put 4 peppermints in with 3 CBS in a 400 gal. Don't know if the peppermints are still there But I haven't seen any of them in a couple of months now

 

[puks]

Have 5 PPS and 1 CBS in 120 gal tank. So far everyone is alive.

 

[Nembo]

I had to get rid of my coral banded shrimp because he killed and ate any other shrimps in the tank including peppermints and that was in a 4ft tank.