best starter crabs?

ryaneisenhart

New member
my new 55g is about to be finished cycling. what are everyones opinions on which crabs are the coolest/best to start the tank with??

also, how many can i put in a 55 FOWLR? can i put them all in at the same time to start?

Thanks for any help!!(and any pics of your pet crabs would be great!!!!!)
 
Electric blue hermits, dwarf blue hermits, dwarf red tip hermits, electric orange hermits, sandsifting crabs, mithrax crabs.

Max amount of hermits should be about 20-25.
Max amount of mithrax crabs is 2.
Max amount of sandifting crabs is about 10.
 
If you think you might keep any coral at all (the temptation is great) then I might stay away from Electric blue and orange hermits. I've banished both for eating polyps. Otherwise they are gorgeous.

For algae control I have had great luck with red tip hermits, and scarlet reef hermits. I also have dwarf zebras, dwarf blue, and some other odd balls.

If your looking for "normal" crabs, I like porcelain and red mithrax crabs. Both are very easy to keep, and very interesting to watch.

As for stocking levels, I wouldn't go as high as Packersfan21 at first. With a new tank you probably don't have the food growing/accumulating to feed them all yet.

I'd start with 10-15 hermits. Mix up the species if ordering online. Either a porcelain or mithrax (probably a mithrax) I'd also get some snails and a fighting or sand sifting conch.

For snails I like 5-10 cerith, 5 trochus, 5 nassarius, 5 nerite, 2-5 turbo, and 2-3 Astrea undoza (my favorite for wiping out unwanted macro algae). I haven't had much luck with 'normal' astreas. . .

Then, without being overly reactive, I'd add additional cleaning livestock as needed.

Just because I'm listing my preferred tank cleaners, I also think 3-4 peppermint shrimp or a pair of scarlet skunk cleaner shrimp make a great addition. I definitely recommend the cleaners if your getting any tangs, but your tank is really too small for a tang.
 
Here are the crabs I'd recommend for a reef:

scarlet reef hermits: Awesome algae eaters, very thorough, but will pick at coralline and get kinda big. Not aggressive IME

Porcelaine crab: A decorative crab. Very peaceful and good looking.

Those are the only crabs I would trust in a tank with anything else. Any other crab can turn at any moment, including emeralds. just IMO but no crab is to be really trusted. Avoid sally litefoots like the plague. They are very well known fish eaters.

Dan
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11704225#post11704225 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by amutti
If you think you might keep any coral at all (the temptation is great) then I might stay away from Electric blue and orange hermits. I've banished both for eating polyps. Otherwise they are gorgeous.

For algae control I have had great luck with red tip hermits, and scarlet reef hermits. I also have dwarf zebras, dwarf blue, and some other odd balls.

If your looking for "normal" crabs, I like porcelain and red mithrax crabs. Both are very easy to keep, and very interesting to watch.

As for stocking levels, I wouldn't go as high as Packersfan21 at first. With a new tank you probably don't have the food growing/accumulating to feed them all yet.

I'd start with 10-15 hermits. Mix up the species if ordering online. Either a porcelain or mithrax (probably a mithrax) I'd also get some snails and a fighting or sand sifting conch.

For snails I like 5-10 cerith, 5 trochus, 5 nassarius, 5 nerite, 2-5 turbo, and 2-3 Astrea undoza (my favorite for wiping out unwanted macro algae). I haven't had much luck with 'normal' astreas. . .

Then, without being overly reactive, I'd add additional cleaning livestock as needed.

Just because I'm listing my preferred tank cleaners, I also think 3-4 peppermint shrimp or a pair of scarlet skunk cleaner shrimp make a great addition. I definitely recommend the cleaners if your getting any tangs, but your tank is really too small for a tang.


I keep electric blue hermits w/ corals and they never cause any problems. Dwarf zebras can turn destructive in large numbers. Same goes for peppermint shrimp.
 
Back
Top