Compatibility HELP ME, PLEEZ REPLY

[momome888]

i have a question would triacdna clams, seahorses and pipefiish be compatible.

 

[TamiW]

Your question was answered in your earlier thread. The general consensus was no, they are not compatible.

Even if the clams do not directly harm the seahorses, the environmental requirements of a clam is incorrect for seahorses, and vice versa.

 

[Fishfreak218]

nope.... again... you got your answer the first time, no need to repost again just because you didnt like the answer

 

[greenighs]

I've never kept them together. I have been warned by other seahorse keepers that seahorses and clams don't mix. One person I know had to rescue a seahorse from INSIDE a clam, only the head and tail were showing, the entire body was clamped inside. I'd be afraid of hurting the seahorse AND the clam trying to separtate them in a situation like that.

Yes, seahorses and clams have different needs. You can keep asking around, to see if anyone has had experience keeping both together, maybe they'll have a more specific answer as to how it can be done, but I haven't heard of a successful tank with both.

Try a clam forum, maybe. Either way, if enough people say it can't be done, maybe you should take their word for it. If you still want to risk it, please report on how it goes with your tank so we can revise or confirm our advice.

 

[ZoeReef]

I think you abuse the system. You post this thread as if your entire tank is dying and it's only to ask a routine question. Wasn't there some story about a boy crying 'wolf?'

 

[sloshesv]

Yeah, the capital letters in the title is a bit over the top.

 

[momome888]

I have posted many times but no one answered me on the ones I didn't capitalize. And this is true

 

[pledosophy]

Provide a link were a topic of yours was unanwsered in this forum?

The truth is that many of us get tired of anwsering the same question over and over again, especially when it has become apparent that the person is not looking for our input, experience, or advice, but just confirmation of there own thoughts.

I am sure that any topic of yours that has gone unnoticed is purely an oversite.