Cooling for the summer: chiller? Air con? Fans?

Dtip

New member
This will be my first summer with a tank in this climate, in a house with no air conditioning. I'm wondering if anyone has any advice on the best way to get through the summer without boiling my tank: I'm not very familiar with this aspect of reefing, and since just about any option, as far as I know, will be super expensive, I want to make the best choice.

Basically, I have a 55 gal tank, a 10-15 gal sump, and a 6gal bucket RDSB, so estimate around 70gals of water in the system max.

I keep my tank at around 79-80degrees. Normally my room temps are anywhere from 69-72degrees, and the rest is made up by heat generation from lights and pumps and my heater. I've noticed that if the room temps get above 75 degrees, the natural heat from my lights and pumps and so forth makes it hard to maintain the tank at 80: it starts to climb higher than ambient temps even with the heater completely off.

As far as the summer goes, ambient temperatures can get as high as 105 or so in the summer (though that high rarely lasts more than a few hours at most). So worst case scenario, I need to be able to handle these highs, and hopefully ride out even the hottest days: let's say that I need the ability to drop things by about 20 degrees below ambient temps in the worst case scenario.

As I see it, my options are basically:

1) Get a chiller (probably a 1/10 HP unit, but maybe I might need even a 1/6, I'm not sure)

2) Get a heavy duty window air conditioning unit for downstairs where my tank is (we'd have to cool the entire downstairs since we have no doors between rooms)

3) Get a full on full house forced air system.

I can also add some dedicated tank fans, though I don't know if these can really combat up to 20degree ambient temperature differentials.

As far as I can tell pricewise, 1) the cheapest I can find is about 400$ for a 1/10 hp unit, but this is probably the cheapest option to run in terms of electric bills. 2) is cheapest to buy (300$ unit) but probably the most expensive to run. 3) I don't think I have even a remote chance of being able to afford (I have ductwork, but everywhere I look implies several thousand dollars of unit and install costs).

For option 1), I'd basically just need to figure out what the best unit to buy is. Is 1/10 really enough for my system and the temps I need to combat? The downside is that it's a ton of money to heat only the tank. And I'm not sure whether or not these units can really keep up in a house that has no air conditioning period to at least help them out some of the way.

Air conditioning would have other benefits, but would probably cost a lot more in electricity bills in the end, and I'm also not sure that even a HUGE window unit could really drop the entire downstairs temps enough.

None of these are really great options: doing mostly temp work, I don't have a heck of a lot of cash sitting around, so this isn't a decision I want to make hastily, though I'm probably running out of time as things heat up.
 
get a chiller for the tank and AC for you ,,,,,,, i think for the money , a chiller would be more in line for the tank , with 70 gals , when the temps start getting up the in your house, it WILL effect your water temp, and the best way to control 70 gallons of water , is a chiller
the water will stay at a constant temp whatever the house temps are IMO. then get the MONSTER A/C unit for you so you can sit back cool off and not worry about the tank, 1/10 should be fine with 70 gals, if you can go any higher on HP go for it , but 1/10 should keep it just fine and not run allllllllll day either ,,,,
 
I have found this to work wonders. I doubt it will be able to drop 20 degrees. However, it can drop my 250g system about 5-7degrees. Fortunately, here in NE Ohio, the summers are relatively mild with relatively few days over 90. However, with high humidity, evaporative cooling gets pretty difficult. If it were me, I would consider the window AC unit. Expensive to run but will also afford you a little comfort as well as your critters.

http://www.acehardware.com/sm-stanley-and-reg-blower-fan--pi-1747223.html
 
Thats for nano tanks Murphysalt
Way to small to keep up with cooling. on a large tank that chiller would burn up quick IMO.

My bad didn't notice he had a 55 gal tank. thats a good deal on one then. I'd still wait it out though and see if your tank does need cooling. I've got 20 years with all different size reefs and I've never needed a chiller

Erik
 
It depends on your situation and house, but for resale you may want to put A/C in. If it's feasible.
 
Real A/C for the house is probably just too expensive a project for me atm. Our incomes will shoot up in about two years, but for now...

I'm going to set up some fans and see how well I can do with evap for a bit, but that 1/10 is the cheapest I've seen. I'm a little skeptical of their tank size rating but definately something to look into. As far as I can tell, all of these units require a separate small pump rather than having one built into the unit, which seems sort of silly: why add more heat only to take it out again? I guess it doesn't make that much difference, but still...

Kreeger1: My bad didn't notice he had a 55 gal tank. thats a good deal on one then. I'd still wait it out though and see if your tank does need cooling. I've got 20 years with all different size reefs and I've never needed a chiller

What average room temps do you have to deal with in the summer?
 
Back
Top