I've heard bad things about them due to the fact they rely on a pump to remove air from the siphon. I've been using one for about 3 months, and the hose from the pump does occasionally clog, but it hasn't proved disastrous (tank didn't overflow). Mine only partially clogs, resulting in the overflow still flowing, but going slower than the return pump. This happens until the sump gets low on water and the pump starts pumping in air and water together, which slows the pumps output down so it can't overflow the tank.
If I had it to do over, I'd get the overflow with the U-tube that doesn't rely on a pump to keep the siphon going.