I've never used the Giesemann in anything but T5 so i can't speak for their MHs but I've had excellent color out of GSPs under XM, Ushio, Radium, & Hamilton bulbs from 10-20 kk, I've had them turn brown under NEW CoralVue (10, 14 and 20 kk lamps) and very old URI VHOs but they quickly color back up once put under good lighting.