Hawaiian Harlequin Shrimp

howze01

New member
Has anyone here ever tried to pair up a "normal" Harlequin with a Hawaiian one? Also, has anyone ever done a trio of Harlequins? I have a pair of the "normal" ones and would love to add a Hawaiian if possible. I know more than one pair won't normally work but I haven't seen any info on trios. Thanks for any help!
 
In my reading it seems that the normally seen Harlequins are of the Picta variety. Supposedly the Elegans variety is a bluer version. I haven't seen anywhere saying that the Hawaiian is the Elegans. I actually normally see them under Picta. Do you have a link showing the Hawaiian as Elegans?

I read on Chuck's Addiction that more than one pair won't work because they will fight. It also said that the male may try to steal another male's female. That led me to think that trios may be possible. Have you tried trios? Did you read that?

I haven't been able to find a ton of info about them other than pretty basic stuff. If you (or anyone else) have good links I would love to read them.

Thanks!
 
II haven't seen anywhere saying that the Hawaiian is the Elegans. I actually normally see them under Picta.

That's at least what you know for now. Hymenocera picta is only found in Hawaii so far while Hymenocera elegans can be found throughout Indo-Pacific.

If you (or anyone else) have good links I would love to read them.

Hymenocera is almost always found in single or pair (monogamy mating) and I would expect they behave similarly in our tanks. Here is further reading regarding their social and mating behavior:

THE INFLUENCE OF SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT ON SEX DETERMINATION IN HARLEQUIN SHRIMP (HYMENOCERA PICTA: DECAPODA, GNATHOPHYLLIDAE)
Harlequin shrimp, Hymenocera picta, are monogamous and pair-bonding, and are usually found in isolated singles and pairs in the field. The apparent rarity of this species in their habitat and high levels of aggression between consexuals suggests the possibility of some sort of plasticity in their primary sex determination. In this study, the influence of social environment upon primary sex determination in H. picta was examined experimentally in the laboratory. Naïve juveniles were placed in three novel social environments: paired juveniles, single juveniles, and adult/juvenile pairs. Spacing behavior and the onset of external differentiation were observed during long-term experiments for each social treatment. Gonadal development was also observed. Spacing behavior of paired shrimp reflected the sexual composition of social groups; high intrapair distance (IPD) for same-sex pairs and low IPD for opposite-sex pairs. Sex determination results were not so clear. Two of the three paired juvenile replicates displayed phenotype frequencies different from those expected from a random sample of gonochoristic organisms with a 1:1 sex ratio. However, the third replicate and the combined frequencies did not show any statistical difference from the hypothetical random sample. Furthermore, single juveniles and those paired with adults expressed sex in nearly 1:1 ratios, regardless of the sex of adult conspecifics. Histological examination of juvenile shrimp confirmed that sex was determined as early as four weeks after larval metamorphosis. Therefore, social environment had no clear effect upon sexual phenotype expressed. However, single females attained puberty at a significantly greater age and larger size than did females paired with males. Hence for H. picta, social environment had a measurable effect on the timing of female puberty. This is the first demonstration of this phenomenon in decapod Crustacea.

You can do a little more research from the followings:

Sense of smell and pair bond in Hymenocera picta Dana. Micronesica 9:231"“236.
Biology of Hymenocera picta Dana. Micronesica 9:225"“230.

Hope this helps.
 
Good reading dzhou, thanks! I've been reading for about the past hour now!

It seems I'm either going to have to trade my pair in or set up another little tank for just a single Hawaiian. I may just be better off sticking to my pair I have now rather than fixing that which is not broken.
 
I had a female picta, and a male elegans. I thought they were both pictas at first. They co-existed, shared there food, and when they were done eating they would wonder off away from each other. Never bothered each other. But if you have a pair, and then a loner there may be a fight for a mate.
 
Back
Top