Posting this in the Zoanthid forum, instead of the Soft coral forum, might get you more suggestions, advice and help. Did you dip or treat them with anything? I'd suggest dipping them in Melafix. Might have Zoanthid eating Nudis. They're almost impossible to spot, as they are typically the same color as the Zoanthids they're eating. Dipping will kill the nudis, but not the eggs. You'll need to inspect the colonies very closely, for egg masses. I suggest using a magnifying glass.