Ok, so I didn't find this "incredibly rare" zoa... but pretend I did. I have this zoa/paly that I think is really cool looking. It's not listed in any of the coral ID sites, I've never seen pictures of one quite like it before, and it's not available from any of the big-name RC sponsors that sell zoa frags/colonies: LiveAquaria, Dr. Mac's, Vivid, Reef Hotspot, etc.
So, I post a picture of it. Maybe I give it a name. If lots of people tell me they want a frag... and I sell a few, have I gone too far?
At what point have I violated the "Responsible Zoanthid Owner's Code of Conduct?" At what point am I contributing to the "demise" of this hobby? Does it depend on how much I paid for my frag... and how much I sell mine for? Or, better yet, does it depend on my original intent?
It's one thing if there's misrepresentation involved: using someone else's picture, getting "friends" to chime in and hype a coral. But, short of that, why is there so much complaining in this forum about the prices and practices of seemingly everyone who sells any zoas/palys?
There are countless examples of people paying "just plain stupid" prices for acros, for many acans, for an unbelievable number of chalices, and yes, for plenty of paly/zoas. But, it doesn't seem like pricing and selling practices topics are nearly as predominant in the other forums as they are here...
It seems like we've collectively spent enough effort trying to "protect the ignorant" and "save the hobby." Perhaps, except in cases of outright fraud, we should let the fools be parted from their money, and just be thankful that many of the mini-frag-sized "collector" corals that fetch outrageous prices are an aquaculturing success story.
Just a thought....