Looking for a non aggressive blue fish

ntropics

Member
I have a butterfly and angel dominated tank:
180 gallon with ~50 gallon sump and refugium total after live rock ~ 200 gal of water.
8' X 2' high X 18" front to back. I originally planned on putting a naso tang in there, but have not yet. No coral to speak of (one soft coral).
Current fish:
BUTTERFLIES: Chaetodon miliaris (lemon)
C. semilarvatus
C. auriga
C. falcula
ANGELS: Centropyge bicolor
C. ferugata (rusty)
Pomacanthus navarchus (blue girdled/majestic)
FILEFISH: Paraluteres prionurus (mimic toby puffer filefish)
DARTFISH/ Nemateleotris decora (purple firefish)
FIREFISH


The fire fish hides out usually. I see him once per week or so.
As you can tell, just about every fish is predominantly yellow, maybe with a bt of blue, but mostly yellow. I was originally trying a Hawaii biotype but that seems to be going by the wayside at this point.

Anyway I was interested in something along the lines of Thalassoma lunare, the Lyretail wrass, but I understand it is quite aggressive. I am really not a hippo tang fan, so I have ruled that out.

My auriga is somewhat aggressive and killed a couple of fish: my other purple firefish, my tassle filefish, but left others alone. There is very little aggression among the butterfly fish, and the angels also seem to leave each other alone. I am concerned about upsetting the balance that I have. My live rock has lots of caves and hiding spots.

Any suggestions? Do I even have room for a naso in that tank if that's what I were to consider?
Thanks!
Bruce
 
Thanks. I was heading toward the wrasses. We like the Cirrhilabrus wrasses a lot, (although we were wishing we could get a Thalassoma lunare) Scott's fairy wrass is pretty cool. I have had chromis in the past and they do the 5-4-3-2-1 thing of killing each other. And while I love the dartfish, they tend to hide, at least in my tank. I have a purple firefish (in the dartfish group) and he only comes out once in a while.
Aslo thought about the coral beauty angel (Centropyge bispinosus). Any more ideas?
Does anyone have anyexperience with the Thalassoma wrasses, and are they as mean as some say?
Thanks again!
 
Let me add two other possibilities that I thought of: Lieutenant tang or lavender tang. Aren't these supposed to be less aggressive for acanthurus? And is there any truth that they eat hair algae?
 
How about a small group of Purple Reef Chromis (Chromis Scotti) - if you can find them? They are much bluer in person than in some of the online pics.
 
Last edited:
Have you thought of powder blue tangs or sapphire damsels? OR, you could just get a bunch of cleaner wrasses :p
 
I am quite in the same boat as you, except for some reason all my fishes are orange. :D Ocellaris clown, skunk clown, firefish and flasher wrasse. I also want more blu

A blue green chromis is already in QT. I am considering the followings

- Coral beauty angel (I want a really blue specimen)
- purple tang
- blue tang (prefer not to as I want it to be a rock picker)
- Powder blue tang (also prefer not too, prefer hardy fishes)
 
Hi Navyblue, love the powder blue, but too mean! Purple tangs as well. I had a coral beauty, and it did well, for four years, then suddenly weakened and died. Age maybe? But I guess I am thinking of something bigger, sort of like my main big fish. Also thought of a pair of blue jaw triggers.

Everyone has been really helpful. I am still looking!

Bruce
 
Back
Top