My latest DIY adventure

thanks for all of the kind words. Hopefully in a couple of months I will still be happy with my design decisions :D
 
I can always help you build your own. :). I learned alot with this project... alot of "what to do" and even more of "what not to do". What are you trying to accomplish with it ?
 
I'm setting a 50G tank (30" long) the stand can only fit 25" long sump.
Any idea how much it would cost to make a 25" long sump?
 
one thing I have learned over the last couple of projects is that it always costs less to buy something used and almost always costs less to buy something commercial (versus building it yourself, material cost wise). The main advantage to building one yourself is that you can have it exactly fit your needs, whether it be completely utilizing available space, or being set up just how you need it to be to match your drains and return lines, or pumps and skimmer, etc.

How tall would you want the sump to be ? 25" long is rather short (I may actually have a spare one up in the attic that we could work out a trade for).

Here is where I almost always start : This is the web page I use for "designing" any tanks that I build. It helps to size the acrylic for thickness and dimensions so all I need to do is take the cut list to the local Tap Plastics for them to cut (which they do on the spot, unless it is an odd shape, which none of these would be)


http://www.garf.org/tank/BuildTank.asp


You can figure for tap plastics that 1 sq ft would cost approximately :

per sq ft.

1/4" $6.00
3/8" $10.15
1/2" $13.60
3/4" $22.50


The sq footage is calculated as the overall sum of the different pieces, not how much of your cut list they can cut out of one of their sheets, which works out in our favor.


I chose a 16" X 16" X 25" tank as the "frame" for your sump (wider, taller or shorter all change the price, up or down). Oft times changing the dimensions changes the thickness of acrylic that their calculator says is required. So making it a little shorter could allow for using 1/4" rather than 3/8", knocking $40 off the price). That comes out to approximatley 12 SQ ft. At $10 per sq ft for 3/8" you are looking at $120 for the sump itself, figuring another $15 per baffle, for a basic bubble trap it adds $45 (3 baffles) ouch !!.

Sp you can see why it is often cheaper to find it commercially (where they buy raw materials in bulk and mass produce the units) or buy something used and use it as is, or do minor (or major) modifications to make it fit your purposes and needs.


Send me the exact dimensions that you are looking for and I will go up into the attic and check what I have up there. I know I have at least 2 sumps up there (both commerical, one a TruVu "Deluxe") and one of them may be what you are looking for.
 
I read about it, and it looks really nice. I even already have the check valve and other components that they used. I had considered a small one, just to see how it would look/work, but I recall reading that it was required to be dead on level to actually work properly. I am fairly handy with wood working (built a deck around our raised hottub, including stairs leading up to it, all from scratch and have copleted various other such projects), but I admittedly am unsure if I have the capacity to accomplish something at that level. I am also unsure where I would put it currently. Our fish room (garage) is either already housing tanks and equiptment or is allocated for upcoming upgrades. No place to really put it, inside or out, but I would still love to have a go at it, just to try it :)

P.S. I have an update to my last post in the main thread referrenced above, but my web hosting company had a HDD failure and are in the middle of replacing the drive and rebuilding the RAID, so the server is offline currently (I guess they figured it would go alot faster and be safer if they rebuilt it offline, which is would be). Once it is back I have several updates to post with more pictures. :)
 
BTW, they finally finished the work on my web hosting server, so the pictures are back online, as well as I posted the updates on the ozone reactor modifications (otherwise known as repairs :)) and few other details about the prop tank, etc
 
thanks for the compliment. Yea, I did spend quite a bit, as I chronicled in the thread.. close to 3 solid weeks of every waking minute after work and all weekend (going to sleep close to midnight most nights), but I lack patience, so I pushed to get it finished :). That didn't count the preparation, planning and design time (and I also left out the prop tank move and "Stand/Shelf" build time). I finished the prop tank a month or so ago and finally finished planning and ordered all of the materials and parts and started on the sump a couple of weeks ago. :). Looking at it now, it was worth it though :) (even the wife thinks so), not to mention that it is worlds quieter out there and even in the house now, no more mag drives "humming" (that could be heard through the walls if/when one happend to lean to far up against the old sumps walls). We also cut down the eletrical usage as the sequence pump is quite a bit more efficient than the numerous mag drives we used to use, and also the chiller is used less (less tank/water heat from the external pump versus all of those internal ones).

I am still ticked off at RedSea for the run around I have so far recieved today regaring this 7 month old ozoner (that still looks brand new, since I took very good care of it). I am considering jsut replacing it (with another brand) and selling this one when they finally warranty repair/replace it. Very frustrating.....
 
Back
Top