Nassarius or not

I don't think there is a more credible source for classifying and identifying sand critters than Dr. Shimek. This article is way more than anybody needs to know about whelks:
http://www.reefkeeping.com/issues/2005-11/rs/index.php

With the exception of one group, whelks are not animals that are, or should be, welcome in a normal reef aquarium. The exceptional whelks that do well in reef aquaria, and which are good neighbors to all animals in the reef tank, are the nassariids. These animals, mostly in the genus Nassarius, but also including a few other small genera, are typical whelks in all regards except their diets. They are specialized to eat only carrion. In reef tanks, they eat excess meaty food before it can rot, and they eat recently deceased or dying organisms. Probably as a result of their specialization upon carrion, which in nature is found on the surface of sediments, nassariids typically have a proportionally shorter proboscis than other whelks. They can't reach deep into spaces to eat worms, nor can they drill holes through clam shells. They can, however, and do clean up excessive meaty foods very efficiently.
 
Lol just noticed that cloak linked to the same article
Once you make it through the Jurassic period, it get pretty interesting. The part about how they poke through shells to eat clams is nice and gory :)
 
I posted both of the OP's pictures in the Other Invertebrates Forum and one of the gurus there confirmed that it is indeed a Whelk. (Pagojoe)
 
Joe, they are whelks you need to get rid of them. If you have a sump then put them in it. Otherwise they will eat things you don't want them to.

Can't comment on whether to get rid of them, but not a big fan of putting unwanted shelled critters in sump due to danger of fouling pumps. Bring it back to store or dump it, IMO.

Mike
 
Ok I was able to get 2 of them out of the tank and in a cup. I was taking a look at their body's and their whole body and snout have that spotted look. Do I let them be and give them a chance or keep them in the cup until i can go to the LFS
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    56.1 KB · Views: 4
Back
Top