protein skimmer suggestion

[shyland83]

I am looking to replace my protein skimmer, i have a 29 gallon with a 10 gallon sump and plan on putting the skimmer in the sump. Here are the ones i have been looking at, I would love some feedback and suggestions, and any other suggestions would be great. thanks

http://www.thatpetplace.com/Product...ers/T1/F49BA+0062+0125/EDP/1197/Itemdy00.aspx

http://www.thatpetplace.com/Product...rs/T1/F49BA+0047+1047/EDP/46799/Itemdy00.aspx

http://www.thatpetplace.com/Product...rs/T1/F49BB+0462+0347/EDP/33348/Itemdy00.aspx

 

[Iam]

I am looking for the same type of skimmer..
(I've been using bakpak 2 for my other tank) and I am really happy with it..
Now I need one for 30g seahorse tank..
I just wanted give you another link

https://www.marinedepot.com/aquariu...super_needle_wheel_venturi_system.asp?CartId=

you'll find Coralife Needle Wheel a little cheaper..just so you know..

 

[powdertang05]

sea clone is crap do not buy if you want one ill sell you one really cheap! its hard to keep it skimming and need to be adjusted all the time. as for the red sea its worse then the sea clone it need much more adjustment and give no skimate. for the coralife Super skimmers i think that would be the best choice out of them all dont have one but have heard they work fine. if i was you i would get a sump and get a in sump skimmer and save up as much money as i can the skimmer is your main product that does everything for your tank if its a crappy cheap one you will get crappy results remember, "what you pay for it is what you get" it was hard to figure that out when i started reefing so your ahead of the game now.