Selling My House, and My Tank

terry4505

New member
Hey guys,

After having our house on the market since May, the day has finally arrived!

We received an offer on our house yesterday. But, to our surprise, the buyer asked that I leave my tank in the offer.

I currently have a mature, 120 gallon mostly SPS reef chock full of corals and fish I am pretty emotionally attached to.

The tank is plumbed to the basement, where the sump is.

At this point, I am not sure how the tank effects the value of the house.

Fish and corals aside, I think the value of the equipment breaks down something like this:

Tank and stand- $200 (both are older, tank has some scratches, but great ricordeas growing all over the overflows and lots of character)

light- $600- I retrofitted an old 8 bulb Tek light with two Gen 3 radions by removing the middle four bulbs. So it is a custom build T5/LED combo, I may be undervaluing this

Circ pumps- Maxspect Gyre 150, Vortech MP10- $300

Apex with B/O, float switches, and wireless camera- $400

Reactors (BRS single and dual) $100

Doser, containers and chemicals- #100

6 Stage RO/DI- $100

Skimmer- Vertex Omega 150, works like a boss $300

various equipment, mixing containers, pumps, powerstrips, etc. $100

-----------------

So just the equipment is somewhere in the ball park of $2500, and I think I am being conservative. I am planning on setting up a new tank in the new house (a 120, peninsula style with a Ghost Overflow) but was planning on reusing all of the equipment except for the tank and stand.

So I am looking at what it is going to cost me to replace what I have. I have acquired most of this stuff slowly, over time, sometimes off of Craigslist etc. So to buy it all again is going to be a major cost.

I also don't want to lose our chance to sell the house because I am being a stickler about the cost of my tank.

One other thing to keep in mind, is prior to the tank being plumbed to the basement, there were frequent sump overflows from skimmers etc., and the hardwoods under the stand took a beating. I have no idea how bad they will be when we move the stand. It may costs thousands to repair them, and I would love to be able to leave the tank and avoid the hassle.

So my question is, if the buyer is interested in the tank, it shouldn't be a detriment to the price (as I have seen said a lot as I have searched around) so how should I value the tank? How should it impact the selling price?
 
If the new buyer wants it, personally I would let them. The problems you could run into from the flooring you mentioned to cracking the tank during the move or anything in between. The hassle of breaking down with possible loses to fish and coral. You would probably scare him away from the idea with anything more than 1000-1500, I would buy new and exactly what I wanted if spending anymore than that. Just my two cents to give you a reefers view with an in wall tank myself(mine will be going with the house very cheap so I don't have to fix the wall and I can upgrade to larger lol). Good luck with whatever choice you make and with your move.
 
Last edited:
take some large frags of all your sps with you to their new tank

Tried to add this above but I haven't had my coffee yet
 
Is this buyer experienced?

If not, think of the potential handholding that will take place for many months after the sale. That leaves the door open for discussing any short comings with the house as well.
 
I would leave it, especially if its a full priced offer- heck- i would counter offer that their contract that you get to pick out some frags to re-stock your new tank when the time comes. Seems pretty fair to me.
 
I did the same thing you did, I sold my house in the buyer bought my tank. I picked their brain to see if they were willing to keep up with the regular maintenance and cost of things. I sold mine and got about 100% of my return of investment. It also led to me having a nicer and bigger tank in my new house. It was very bittersweet to leave the old tank because I did become attached to it. I was also worried about the conditions of the flooring underneath. I didn't want to have to repair or replace the flooring on the day of closing. Good luck
 
After countering, he decided he didn't want the tank that badly. So we agreed on a price for the house and have an agreed to purchase agreement. This has been a long process and feels weird that it is coming to an end.

I am going to contact him and see if he is interested in the tank, stand, plumbing to the basement, sump and return pump. I am upgrading anyway, I don't want to move what I don't have to
 
that would be great if he goes for that. He'd get a nice start into reefing and you wouldn't have to take all that down and do repairs. Fingers crossed......lol
 
lol can't pm don't have 10 post.lol interested in tank & stand. if still a sale option.. in syracuse can pic up this weekend?
 
Back
Top