Someone has an opinion???

21Reefman

New member
I posted this question earlier, and received zero replies. Anyone? Bueller, Bueller??

When to feed What?

I was curious as to when to feed what size food? I have a few heavily stocked mixed reefs.
To feed, I have; marine snow, phytoplankton (DT's, &Bioplankton), rotifers (phytofeast), Cypopeeze (frozen), zooplankton (frozen), and frozen brine/mysis mixes like marine cuisine and emerald entree.

So, my question(s); Should I feed small particle foods, like phytoplankton in the morning or evening?
Is there any sequence of food particle size that occurs in the ocean?
When all the micro-organisms come out at night, are they stirring nutrients up into the water column,
or removing nutrients, so that suspended food has been consumed by morning?
*When does the fluctuation of heat from day to night cause the currents to bring nutrient rich upwellings up from deep water?*
When do the larger zooplankton tend to be actively presented as food for the reefs?
Is it best to feed small and then later feed larger particles or vice-versa?

All that being presented, I will say how I tend to feed; I used to feed 2X a day, now days I'm down to 1X every few days, or 1X per day. I usually feed the smallest particle size first as to get my turbastea to open, I give it some time to simmer, and for the food to be absorbed (no return/skimmer), Then I put in some cyclopeeze followed by a cube of either the marine cuisine or emerald entree (this is for the fish). If I have time/ambition I feed zooplankton directly to the sun-corals via XL syringe (I got it from a bar, it was filled with liquor and holds like 3 shots) I sometimes have cyclopeeze and phyto in the syringe as well. I hit the favia and blasto's with this also. They love It!
I was starting to build up too many nutrients from all the food but, I stayed on top of things and now parameters are perfect again. It took some serious house cleaning but should be done regularly anyway. I get away with feeding every few days because I took out the fish in one tank. The other tank that still has fish is fed 1x per day, most days. Sometimes more, sometimes less.

I know that my ecosystem would benefit most, from a constant supply of the right amount of phyto but, an auto doser just is not on the horizon yet. So until then what would be your suggestions on; When to Feed What?
 
OK--I'll give you a rather uneducated opinion. While it's always a good idea to try to reproduce natural ecosystems as much as possible, I think often it's not practical, and sometimes not necessary. Your corals are now used to a captive system, with the feeding regimen you've set, and drastically changing it to simulate a natural environment might actually be disturbing to them.

I think more frequent, smaller feedings are more efficient. but I think probably just establishing a routine that your corals can acclimate to is the most important thing.
 
Good point. I do agree that they have adjusted to my feeding habits but, is that the best I can do?
What about the theory that; as a creature that evolved over millions of years, it has adapted to feeding within its environment.
If that environment includes a constant supply of food, then the coral would never need to store excess food for later (continued) consumption? Thus having a "small stomach", which would never benefit from large infrequent meals. As I read somewhere "it would be like if you only ate thanksgiving dinner once every 14 days, you might survive but, I bet you won't be very happy about it".
So I think in some cases small frequent feedings are necessary for the corals/fish to really thrive.
Mimicking the natural feeding habits, whenever you start, is the best thing for all marine life:)
 
I don't get it.... Out of 41 people only 1 has anything to add? I thought for sure someone out there could enlighten me with some knowledge:)
 
We have several tanks with our most prized being a 180 sps and a heavy stocked 75 lps, all they get are water changes and sometimes cyclopeeze. Works for us.
 
I feed a mix of foods every other day. I used to use DT phytoplankton but this tends to cause algea problems in my tank. I think establishing a good routine based on theory or peoples experience is what needs to be done. There is no right or wrong here. some people feed daily some never and many feed somewhere inbetween. My thought is judge your routine by the coral and fish. If the color on the fish remains vibrant they are active and free of disease and if the coral seems to be thriving...good color and polyp extension and growth then what and when you feed is enough.
I do not think you will get a response that will give you a stedfast meal plan to live by.
 
I don't think that all of those additional food are necessary. I feed the fish, sometimes cyclopeeze, and do water changes. My tank is going well and is stocked with mostly SPS, but I also have LPS and Softies in the mix. Good luck.
 
Thanks for the input Chris. I think your right, especially when the light is bright enough. I do tend to go days without feeding (if there are no anthias in the tank) and when I do, I don't always run through all those foods, my be 1-2 kinds, depending on what I feel like.
I was looking for scientific info on when the reef is abundant with what size food particle, I guess I will need to dive into the books.
Thanks, for the feedback:)
 
I feed in stages to coax these guys out for target feeding::)
IMG_7878email.jpg


Here is the 20gal
IMG_7830email.jpg


This 92 gets fed maybe one cube once every 1-2 days, and I add rotifers 1-3 times per week as well.
IMG_7192email.jpg


I figured we needed some pics:)
another...
zoamystyer.jpg
 
Why do some zoa's eat meaty foods, while others never grab the food when it lands on them? How can you tell these 2 apart (aside from feeding it)?
 

Similar threads

Back
Top