Symbiotic Relationships and Compatibility

comprisedpuma

New member
Hello RC -

New member here, brand new hobbyist looking to build a stunning saltwater reef aquarium. I will probably go with a 47 gallon bowfront that I have found, but I'm not locked into it yet. Might go bigger, but probably no bigger than 85 gallons.

One of the things I'm very excited about is observing natural symbiotic relationships. I plan on getting an anemone and at least 1 clownfish to go with it. I would also like to get a yellow goby and a trigger shrimp. What are some other symbiotic relationships that I could look into with my tank?

I'm also concerned with compatibility. Obviously Google is a resource I use, but as you probably remember when you were brand new to the hobby, there is sooooo much information and sometimes it can feel daunting with the aggression levels, water balancing, tank locations, etc.... So I was hoping someone could help me with this a little bit.

In addition to the live rock, I'd like to include a variety of soft and hard corals. I've also mentioned the anemone, clowns, goby, and trigger shrimp. But I'd also like a cleaner shrimp (I am leaning towards the coral banded shrimp.. but I've also heard that he can be really aggressive/a bad cleaner?), a purple firefish, maybe a tang, a small clam, some snails/hermits, even possibly a starfish (chocolate chip?) if it would work. I'd really like a seahorse but I understand that would be a bad idea and possibly even a death sentence for the poor guy given what else I plan to put in? What about pipefish instead of a seahorse, or is that also a bad idea?

I'd appreciate any insight from this community on my plans, whether or not they are a good idea, and if any of the things I'd like to add would be a bad idea. I'd also love suggestions for other symbiotic relationships that I could add, or just other fish/inverts in general that would go well with my tank.

PS: I'd *love* a sea cucumber, but I understand this is probably a really awful idea for a newbie? Thanks!
 
Montipora corals and crabs

Anemone and anemome crab

Tuxedo urchin sticks polyps and stuff to it
 
PomPom crab is a very cool addition, although very small and quite reclusive.

I prefer a Fire Shrimp to the Coral Banded, but to each their own. I've not heard as many stories of the Fire Shrimp bothering fish. Mine does steal food from the mouths of some corals, but once I quit worrying about it, I found it didn't bother the coral any.

Read the "Setting Up" thread, there is a HUGE wealth of information contained there that will serve you well as you get started. http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1031074
 
Welcome to RC!

-Clams often require special placement, addition of certain elements, & strong light capability. I'd wait until you have a mature tank & some experience.

-47 gallons is too small for any Tang. Almost all species need a minimum of a 5'-6' long tank

-Sea horses require a dedicated tank, usually cooler than most reefs with lower flow and no competition for food. Check out the forum on them on RC.

-Pipedish are difficult to keep in a standard reef aquarium, but it has been done. Feeding is an issue.

-Research starfish. Certain species can be problematic in your typical reef tank.

-Go with the biggest tank you can. A 47 gallon is really only suitable for fish under 3"-4" adult size. The bigger tanks can support a greater variety of fish and more of them.

-Take the time to read the stickies at the top of this forum and the others on this web site. Virtually all important topics are covered in a comprehensive way. It's worth the time and much better than searching through the jungle of information that is Google.
 
Back
Top