The differences are subtle, in mm, but the issue I have encountered before is the propeller blade is correct but the magnet is wrong, a different magnet is used for 50Hz, it is slightly longer and wider. I think we can be sure that the propeller assembly is the issue as it is the only thing I know of that can cause this besides calcium build up or fine debris caught between the shaft and drive unit or use on a wave maker where frequent start and stop results in breakage and spinning backwards. If you email me a copy of the receipt we will get replacements out to you.