a little skimmer advice

[davester1]

I need a hang-on skimmer which I will be using for just a few months to keep some livestock alive in a 150g tub. Can you make a suggestions regarding the style/brand.

I have seen:
CPR Bak-Pak Dual Protein Skimmer
Aqua C Remora Pro Skimmer
AquaC Urchin protein skimmer

Once my setup is complete, i will only be using it for a quarrantine tank or whatever.

Thanks,
Dave

 

[stevem650]

The Remora Urchin and pro are basically the same except one is hang on and the other is in sump. I would also use the mag 3 with either one if possible and they are good skimmers. I don't know much about the CPR. Also, Remora's are rated for aquariums 75gal up.

 

[NanoKat]

I have an old (about 5 years) CPR BakPak on my 15 that used to be on my husband's 29. It's worked perfectly and only needed routine maintenance. I replaced the powerhead once, but ended up that the old one was okay, just needed a good soak in vinegar to get it going again. So now I have a backup for when I am cleaning one. I always get a good amount of skimming out of it.