Angels and sponge

Kent E

One Millionth Poster
Premium Member
I remebered that I heard something about angels needing songe in their diet. Is this true? I have a small emperor in my tank. I have had no worries because the tank is loaded with sponge. If it requires it and grows larger that supply will dwindle quickly.

Also, I was considering a blueface. If they both required sponge I would have to fins a supply. Any and all thoughts would be appreciated.
 
Most of the large angels feed mainly on sponge in the wild but most of them will do fine on other foods. There are several angel formula foods on the market which contain sponge if you really want to feed it. I dont think either the emp or blueface really need sponge in their diets.
 
I guess on occasion I could buy sponge from the LFS at a premium and see how it goes.
 
Rather than buying sponges, I would agree with kahuna tuna and suggest you get them the angel formula food, which already contains sponges.
 
Is there any truth to the idea that if you get an angel as a juvenile, they are more apt to learn to eat the prepared foods and not nip on the reef / LR? I've read this in a few different books but want to make sure before I take the plunge?

Thanks,
Lisa
 
I make my own food and it cost a fraction of store bought and has more in it. One thing I don't know how to get a hold of is sponge.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6573224#post6573224 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Kent E
I guess on occasion I could buy sponge from the LFS at a premium and see how it goes.
aren't certain sponges poisonous?
 
From what I understand angels in the wild are pretty particular as to which sponges they eat. I had an asfur that would eat sponge formula but he wouldn't touch any of the half dozen or so species I had growing in the tank from my live rock. I have no idea which species of sponges are in those angel sponge formula's.

Seamommie, juvies angels are a a lot less likely to nip corals but there are no guarantees. I think if you start with a juvie, keep corals they are less likely to sample, keep them well fed, keep them in a larger tank, have a lot of live rock in the tank, and have lots of daytime feeding opportunities like a lettuce clip with nori you can keep angels in a reef tank but even the most well behaved angel can suddenly decide something tastes good. There are also some angels that are much better bets than others as well.
 
Thanks for the suggestions. I am mulling the idea of a French Angel (juv.) and then moving him into a larger tank that I have in the planning stage once he matures a bit. I appreciate all the help - I need as much as I can get.:)
 
Ocean nutrition and Hikari both make angel formula with sponge and both have very good reputations for excellent products. I know there are several other angel sponge diets out there but have never tried them.
 
Sponge in the diet is probably important, but I would be more concerned about ensuring that your angels get some green stuff. I have a Regal Angel that eats both ON Angel Formula (which has sponge) and Formula 2 (which has lots of green stuff). He's a picky eater and doesn't eat much else (but see below). While I'm sure each species, and individual for that matter, has its preferences/requirements, my Regal goes nuts for Formula 2. He used to really like the Angel Formula, but his preference now is clearly for Formula 2.

The green thing may be particular to Regals, as mine will also demolish any live Caulerpa that I put in for him (which I grown in a separate tank now). However, he clearly likes sponge. I know this because I recently added a large (about the size of an orange) Red Ball Sponge (Cliona sp? - not sure on this) to add some colour to my tank and gain some experience with it. Not long after putting it in my tank, My Regal started browsing on it. He doesn't go at it, but clearly takes very small bites. While the bites are barely noticeable, quite often you can observe him doing this as he takes quite an interest in it. I now liken it to a "salt lick" - albeit an expensive one! I also added a largish leather coral that had some yellow sponge attached to the rock it was attached to. My Regal cleaned these up in about a day (no idea what species - the amount was very small). I'm not too concerned about the sponge and if it gets eat over the year - so be it. I don't think this will be likely as he still gorges himself when I feed him the ON frozen foods (which I do 2x day - with a 1 day break every week or so). It was a calculated risk, but as my Regal reins supreme I'm happy to keep him happy.
 
Back
Top