any experiance with Chili soft coral??

jacksonsmom25

New member
I have read that chili soft coral needs no lighting because its a non-photosynthetic coral. The picture I saw of this at this link is beautiful and was wondering if anyone has had this stuff or can offer any advise.
thanks
megan
 
If it's the same one that I'm thinking of, I've heard it's very difficult to take care of. Are there any other names for it?
 
chili corals are actually pretty easy to care for when it comes to nonphotosynthetic corals. they need to be feed phyto or zooplankton and do best in very high current.
 
I don't think It said it had another name...im sure it does..but I don't know what it is.
so im wondering are all non photosynthetic coral difficult to keep?
Would it be ok for a beginner without the expensive lighting? maybe someone can suggest someother corals good for beginners? thanks
 
Penny (Aquacorals) currently has this type in stock. I bought one a year or so ago, but it died. I never could get the flow right, and was not feeding supplements, I just depended on the mature reef to provide--apparently that is not enough, at least in 75 gallons plus refugium.
 
Thats to bad. sorry it didn't work out.
I don't think I will be going to Pennys again.
She has a nice store and good looking fish ect.ect...but she didn't like my tank set up, I was doing it all wrong and wouldn't sell me any fish..A 45min drive for nothing but to burn up my gas...I wasn't impressed.
 
I like Penny and her store, but perhaps she is a bit too attached to the DSB set-up. It has worked for her, but I believe there are quite a few good stategies.
 
Just to be fair to Penny and her store, I have been a customer of hers for quite a while. As with everything, there's pros & cons with her methods, although, we run our tank exactly like hers, and we have NO issues.
Her logic with not selling certain livestock items, is that in her experience, she doesn't agree with certain things that people want to do, and would rather lose a sale than see something die in someone's tank. She's cares more about the livestock than the almighty dollar, and relies on her conscience rather than her bottom dollar.
I understand where you're all coming from, but I just wanted to help explain her philosophy.
Good luck and I hope everything goes well for you. :)
 
No one including her, would have know if the livestock would have died im my tank or not.. and I understand she cares about the health of the fish she sells, I totally agree, but I think theres a better way to explain things to her "potential" customer rather than making them feel like dirt, and that they are know nothings.

I wish all the best of luck to Penny and her store, Im just say I won't be shopping there at time soon,if at all.
 
Everyone it seems has his or her own theory as to how best to set up a reef tank. I started out with DSB which has worked well for me but tends to look unsightey as it ages. We all can only make recommendations according to our own experience. That said, I have found with most 'advice' it matters as much HOW you say it as WHAT you say. 'nough said. We are ALL learning, and can learn from ANYONE no matter how long in the hobby. Let's try NOT to bash differing oppinions on this forum. I, for one like to try for a give and take approach. Listen to all. Take what you can use. Give what you can. And that's my oppinion. 'Life is like a box of chocolates, no one knows what they are going to get'. Happy reefing, Sue
 
why did this turn out to be bashing anyone...it started out with my opinion also bunsunburners opinion, Penny has her opinions and her own techniques. Great, more power to her...I just didn't agree and now its bashing?
I don't get it..I quess its just to hard to understand people by typing, you don't get to hear tone of voices, facial expresions ect ect.
 
Chili corals (Nephthyigorgia Sp.) are notoriously hard to keep alive in a captive system. This is *almost* a rule when it comes to non-photosynthetic corals. If they aren't obtaining a large part of their energy from the sun, then they require a decent amount of food. This doesn't jive well with trying to keep a nutrient-poor system. I know of one reefkeeper that does keep them with great success, but employs a constant (albeit slow) waterchange of fresh, filtered, natural seawater.

I'm sure there's other ways.. don't get me wrong.

If you are truly interested in these types of non-photosynthetic corals, there's a dendronephthya study group either here on reefcentral or on www.reefs.org - definately the place you want to be. Otherwise, if you're looking for corals, and you happen to have a low-light system right now, I've got some frags that I will happily donate to you.

Don't be too upset about people's opinions. Plenty of folks don't like the way I do things, but it works for me. I've been verbally accosted on more than one occasion for running a bare-bottom tank. As a matter of fact, there's not much conventional about my system at all. Lots of people will read something once and hold it close as gospel. Every year here on reefcentral, there's a brand new jonestown. Heck, it was only 2 years ago that many, many reefkeepers lost hundreds of pieces of corals because they decided to switch to a brand of salt that was praised in one article. Come to think of it, that particular author has some desciples in other methods as well. ;)


Use opinions as guides, and do your own reading and research. Think for yourself.
 
Ewan,
I really appreciate your words. good to know someones a little understanding. I would love to try my hand with your frags...uhhmm..does that sound right? :) I am anxious to know what these frags are? I am also, (maybe this weekend) going to upgrade my lighting a bit...nothing fancy or expensive Im just going to get a bulb thats 50/50 ReefSun. A little better than the 17w flouresent strip thats working on 2 years old. Good at growing algea...nothing else. then...we will see where I go from there...of course this time of year funds are low.
Basically, I saw a pic of the chilli coral, read that they were non-photosynthetic , thinking they would be good for my low lights situation, and was courious about them. If they are hard to do...there probably not right for me...since im a complete Reef virgin.
OH yeah...I did finally get a skimmer CPR BakPac. Its working well.
so get back to me about those frags...and we will see if we could possibly hook up. thanks allot.
megan
 
Megan, CPR bak pak is a great skimmer. I have a CPR Remora and LOVE it. Some corals that are easy to grow and don't need much light are mushrooms, which come in many colors and should look great under your 50/50 lamp and some ricordeas like less light. Also, I think xenias will do allright in less light and will spread right up toward the light. We all have spare xenias and mushrooms from time to time. I ran an Eclipse 10g with 2 15w regular flourescents one 10,000k and one actinic, changeing out the lamps on an annual basis. I maintained a green bubble tipped anemone and his gold striped Maroon clownfish along with a yellow tailed damsel. They stayed in this tank for over a year until I decided I just HAD to have a yellow tang and got a bigger tank. I never ran a skimmer just 10% water changes every week. Remember we're all in this to have fun. I try not to take myself (or anyone else for that matter) too seriously. Happy reefing, Sue
 
Megan, I just reread your post and btw, I don't think the lighting matters a FIG to fish! Corals are another thing. Sue
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=7024182#post7024182 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by smtarr
Megan, CPR bak pak is a great skimmer. I have a CPR Remora and LOVE it.

different animal. The remora is made by aqua-c.

Sorry, I'm an equipment junkie. ;)
 
Back
Top