Thanks a lot for bringing this thread back up. Just spent awhile reading the whole thing as I'm currently looking for a camera myself in the same price range as the OP. My mind has been getting clouded by all the info on dpreview, as well as the temptations of cameras like the rebels and D40's. I just want to have a camera that is good for general family pics, but I would like to get some really good close up pics of my corals ranging from a few inches inside the glass to around 18 inches from the front glass. A lot of info here regarding the add on adaptors and lenses as well. I'm trying to figure out what would best do the job for me, with me not spending more than I really need to. For example, the new G9 is looking nice, but a hefty price tag for a P&S, and I'm wondering if I might do just as well or even better with a cheaper camera and add on lenses. I'm actually still getting really good general pictures with my Nikon Coolpix 3200, but can't do squat with tank shots much.