bare bottom tanks???

hefeweizan

New member
1. How do i calculate how much rock i need in a bare bottom tank?

For every gallon of water how rock should i have???

2. I also read that there is no need for bio-balls...is that correct???

Mike
 
Very subjective on the amount of LR.

Here is 140 lbs in a 6' BB 110 gal
1695_42.jpg


And :uzi: the Bio balls - no need.
 
if i am upgrading from a 45 gallon tank to a 120 gallon tank, can i put all the rocks, corals and fish the same day???

You don't think I should add the bioballs at the beginning just to introduce bacteria....you think the live rock will be able to handle all the load?
 
How much LR do you have and what is your bio load? How long has your 45 been running?

When I upgraded from my 55 to the 110. I moved it all on the same day. We moved to a new house so I had thew 110 already set up. I brought 30 gals or so of water from the 55. Put LR and livestock in coolers. I changed out the water in the new tank with the old, put the rocks in, then the corals and then the fish.
 
My 45 has been up for 5 years...I have 6 fish...

I would like to have the tank setup before but the 120 is going where the 45 gallon is now...
 
I will probably put anywhere between 50 to 100lbs of live rock...I hop to use a lot of new rock because I want to use a lot of branching rocks...that way I can get more flow around the rocks...

Hope much rock to you think I would need as a minimum?
 
If you are thinking in terms of filtration ability of Live Rocks, my advice is, DON'T!!! Our tank should be an object of beauty ... the aquascape determines the amount of live rocks, not the other way around. Otherwise, you will end up with a "shelf" design ... the same as 90% of all tanks in the world!!!

With the advancement of technology, there are ever more ways of setting up a tank ... for some of my tech inclined friends, an over OVER sized skimmer (x 3 or 4 times tank volume) ... in my previous tank, a DSB in the sump with a bare bottom main tank. In both cases, live rocks becomes a supplement, rather than the main filtration option.

Just my PERSONAL preference, I would recommend you a different approach. Most of the beautifully designed tanks are often with large open spaces and very limited amount of rocks. Consider this ...

1. Look at as many pictures as possible. Choose one design that you REALLY like. Try to avoid the typical "shelf" designs.

2. Try to adopt the design in your own tank. Use JUST ENOUGH rocks to acomplish your tank design. In the past, I used too much rocks in my tank, and it just looks like a wall of rocks!! If you keep fishes, I highly recommend an open area.

3. Once you have aquascaped your ideal tank, than plan for your filtration system ... e.g. DSB in sump, skimmer, algae filter, etc. There are so many choices out there now.

This way, you can get a truely beautiful tank, without needing to worry about how filling up your tank with rocks!!!
 
i've seen a lot of BB tanks over-aquascaped. this means, packed jam full of rocks to detract attention away from the barebottom. this is exactly what i found myself doing in one of my bb tanks... if i were to do it again, i'd definitely use less rock. just a thought, but less is sometimes more if you know how to properly aquascape.

keep in mind you can use PVC shelves w/eggcrate to minimize the amount of rock needed to make the tank look full. try to do a search, if you are unfamiliar w/the PVC shelves. HTH :)
 
Back
Top