Black Long Spine Sea Urchin??Good or Bad

sean obergfell

New member
I have a Black Long Spine Sea Urchin in my reef...supposed to be reef safe....However I think it might be eating some of my polys, Zoes and Exania....Does anyone know if they are known to bother corals?

If so he needs to go.

But the kids at the church love him...

Help please...
 
I have a Black Long Spine Sea Urchin in my reef...supposed to be reef safe....However I think it might be eating some of my polys, Zoes and Exania....Does anyone know if they are known to bother corals?

If so he needs to go.

But the kids at the church love him...

Help please...

i had one in my 55g and i placed some nice radioactive zoas in the tank and i witnessed the urchin pick up the small rock they where on and eat them one by one. people say they are "reef safe" but they will and do eat you zoas and such.
 
I have one of those. He really scrubs the rocks clean of coraline. I have lots of softies including zoas and he never touches them. Now, if he runs out of his favorite foods will he eat zoas? I dont know. I guess if that is all he has to survive he might go after them.
 
Black spine Urchin

Black spine Urchin

Depends...

They do eat coraline algae right off the rocks. Which some people do not like. Since many people love the pretty purple / pink coraline.
But some people don't care about having it... that's a choice.

Coral wise, they are supposed to be reef safe. I had one in my old 125 for a few years. it never ate any of my corals. It temporarily disturbed some corals that closed obviously, when it went over them. But they always opened up again after ward unharmed. Even zoas. They always closed but opened after it was gone un harmed. I decided to get rid of it, because I started getting some things that were not really fastened down and it could knock them over in it's travels. But if you fasten EVERYTHING down (putty / glue) etc.. it can't.

I one in my new tank too.. deciding whether to eventually give him away or not.. once I get more corals..

I do know many prize reef tank owners have them in reef tanks chock full of corals!! As matter of fact, more than one "tank of the month" winner on RC has black spines in their tanks. Including last months.

Some of it may be owner choice and just "possibly" an "individual Urchin"...
But for the most part, they are "reef safe".
 
I have had one in my tank. The only reason I got rid of mine is I got tired of picking up everything it kept knocking over everyday.
 
I have one of those. He really scrubs the rocks clean of coraline. I have lots of softies including zoas and he never touches them. Now, if he runs out of his favorite foods will he eat zoas? I dont know. I guess if that is all he has to survive he might go after them.


+1

Cleaned my coraline. I had to put him in the sump. He also grew in size from a quarter to a softball in 3 months.
 
Back
Top