Can anyone help me ID this? good or bad?

[Scottedontknow]

Hello everyone, just saw this pop up in my SUMP the other day and i wasn't 100% sure what it was or if it was good or bad. i just started growing on a piece of rubble rock.

photo host

images hosting

 

[CafeReef]

I'm not sure I should tell you Scotte, does Fiona know?

in all seriousness, tale of two pictures to me, I would go with an algae growth or sponge of some type but hard to tell. I've never seen it. tagging along to see what others think.

PS. Thanks for getting that damn song stuck in my head

 

[Subsea]

Cryptic sponge, while not attractive it filters water and removes DOC.

 

[Scottedontknow]

Cryptic sponge, while not attractive it filters water and removes DOC.

you're sure about that? I just don't want it to cause big problem in later months/years hahaha. do you think it will just stay in my sump?

 

[Scottedontknow]

I'm not sure I should tell you Scotte, does Fiona know?

in all seriousness, tale of two pictures to me, I would go with an algae growth or sponge of some type but hard to tell. I've never seen it. tagging along to see what others think.

PS. Thanks for getting that damn song stuck in my head

BAHAHAHAHAHAHHA gotta love it you have to admit tho its a great song and a great movie