Carbon dosing question

BrentH

New member
I'm having high nitrates around 20 to 25 my p04 is stable at 0.01 to 0.04 without any gfo my corals are suffering I had an alk swing awhile back and. Now high n03 I started dosing vinagar last night and I'm a little nervous ... I dosed 15ml per 100 gallon volume to start my question is can I use a dosing pump ? If I can dose the whole dose need to be done at once or can it be spread out say 2 to 3 times throughout the day .... And how long till u start seeing results?
 
Hello ,

I haven't had a chance to get to your pms but will soon.

Vinegar should be dosed slowly during periods of photosynthes to avoid a rapid pH drop,adosing pump is a nice way to do it. I wouldn't dilute the vinegar though . With a realtively small dose of 15ml for 100gallons it might be ok to dose it a once but spreading it out is better.
 
I have it spread into 2 doses 80ml total for 600 gallon volume .... I'm till loosing some sps slowly I'm not 100 it's the nitrates but I know it's not helping being above 20 I'll keep it at 80 ml for a little while see what happens
 
Thanks tom u don't need to reply to my pm it's basically asking about vinegar dosing and I found your threads on it .... One thing if I dose more then 15ml per 100gal will it lower nitrates faster?
 
Maybe but probably not .Once the bacteria get going on the nitrogen(probably the ammonium variety ) it still takes a while to see nitrate reduction, IME. Sometimes months.I'd double up the dose every week until you hit about 200ml for teh 600 gallon system; that's half of what I currently dose to 650 gallons ( 80 ml vinegar plus 40 ml of vodka which equals anther 320 ml vinegar) but I've been doing it for over 5 years and feed very heavily. Back down on the dose if you see significant amounts of bacterial mass in the tank or cloudy water from a bacterial bloom. Employ a good skimmer. I'd stick at 200ml for a month or so and move up further if necessary from there.
Some have reported a faster drop in the nitrates when using sugar but sugar has caused problems with corals in many tanks including mine even in small amounts.

Some will say 20ppm nitrate is ok for sps. That has not been my experience nor the experience of many folks keeping sps tanks,I know. I don't go over 1ppm even when dosing some nitrate. Again the nitrate level is arguable but ,imo ,it needs to be quite low but not zero particulary for certain types of sps. NSW at the surface of the reefs is around 0.2ppm.

Having said that your issue may not be the nitrate and may relate to some difficulty the corals are having due to other causes like: the alk swing., pests( flatwroms or redbugs) hypoxia etc. Once stn starts it often just keeps going even after the precipitating event is over and corrected. Fragging away dead spots a qaurter inch or so into good tissue is often the only way to save a specimen: while that works often sometimes the frag doesn't make it either.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top