Cleaner shrimp not interested in fish!

P

Pike614

New member
Got a new cleaner shrimp about a month ago, and he will not "clean" any of the fish that approach him for a cleaning. I am not sure if this is normal for some shrimp to prefer frozen and flake foods over cleaning off parasites. Anyone else have any experience with this happening in their system? Is there any way to coax him to clean the fish, or am I just stuck with a cleaner shrimp that doesn't clean?
Thanks!
 
This happens often. You're not the only one. Usually in a captive environment, cleaner shrimp clean drastically less than when seen in captivity. Don't worry about it, and enjoy their beauty.
 
Any better option to help keep the fish clean? They seem to want to get cleaned although there aren't any parasites I can see on them. This is a reef tank, so reef-safe is a must!
 
Low wages, no insurance, inadequate workspace are often cited as causes for a shrimp to behave in this manner. I say can the sucker and get another one.
 
It seems to be more common these days. It could be from captive breeding. I rembemer a time when I would stick my hand in any customers tank they would flock to come clean my hang nails. These days they just wait for food. But none the less they look great and feed the corals with their spawns.
 
Feed the tank less, I was told that if the shrimp isn't hungry he will not clean as much. Might not be right, but worth a try.
 
Are any of the "cleaner wrasses" reef safe? Or do you get the same issue there with them prefering the easy meal when all the fish are being fed.
 
The opposite actually, there isn't enough 'cleaning' for them to do, and they typically starve to death. For what I've gathered, they don't take to prepared foods real well if at all.
 
I had two that stopped cleaning after a while, too. I don't kn0w where AquaKnight is getting his, but all mine did was steal food from the fish and corals.

Pike, get a second one and they will start spawning 1-2X/month. It's a giant feast for the fish and corals. If they won't clean the fish, at least they can help feed them.
 
thanks seapug! I will do just that! He has molted 3 times in the past month, so he is growing for sure...and will swim clear acrossed the tank to grab any food he can! I'll get another one and see what happens!
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=10675398#post10675398 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by seapug
I had two that stopped cleaning after a while, too. I don't kn0w where AquaKnight is getting his, but all mine did was steal food from the fish and corals.

Pike, get a second one and they will start spawning 1-2X/month. It's a giant feast for the fish and corals. If they won't clean the fish, at least they can help feed them.
Click to expand...
There tons of threads out, search 'cleaner wrasse bad' and bunch should pop up. Additionally, they're really a fish that shouldn't be collected from reefs, their presence on the reef is far too important, then to be killing many off in fish tanks for a few survivers...
 
Thanks for the help! I was reading up on the cleaner wrasses as they were recommended to me on another post, I prefer the shrimp! I'll add another shrimp and see what happens!
Thanks!
 
I had two in my 55 that would clean fish occasionally, but would jump to my hand and start cleaning it whenever i put it in the tank. It was pretty funny, but even a bit annoying when i was trying to do something else in the tank. do yours engage in this behavior at all? you might try approaching them slowly or hand-feeding to coax them into it. they get quite tame after a while

as a side note, are cleaner shrimp hermaphroditic, or at least able to change sex? I had two for a long time in my 55, but never noticed any signs of spawning (not sure that I would have). How would I know if they were spawning?
 
I have two pepps in my tank. Usually twice a month or so one of them is carrying a clutch of eggs with it's hind legs. I've never seen it release them, but I have seen them carrying them.
 
They are hermaphrodites and fertilize each other's eggs. Like dcombs, said, they are pretty easy to see when the parents are carrying them. I saw mine release the eggs many times. Usually right after the lights went off at night-- thousands of little tiny shrimp all over the place. Apparently they are very hard to grow out in captivity but read something somewhere about someone who had done it. I'd try but my Flame Hawkfish dispensed with my cleaners a few weeks back. They were nice to have for a while but can't say I really miss them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

J
Ideas for new stock for a 200L reef tank
Replies
6
Views
481
Uncle99
Uncle99
vinstr
Anyone need a Harlequin shrimp?
Replies
1
Views
394
vinstr
vinstr
T
Trying to identify what ate my Torch Coral
Replies
12
Views
256
Uncle99
Uncle99
N
75 gallon set up and stocking advice
Replies
8
Views
2K
Newham94
N
S
Tank Update & Tentative Stocking Plan
Replies
2
Views
127
griss
griss
Back
Top