coral light sensitivity

DMBillies

Active member
I've recently made a lot of changes to my 90 gallon tank, which has now become all SPS. Over the past few weeks I've noticed some changes in the corals (some of which are good, some are worrisome).

First, I got a good test kit for alkalinity and found out that it was running low for quite some time since the other test kit was reading low (down to about 5 :eek1: , now trying to keep it around 7-9 with the better kit). I suspected for a while that my alkalinity was kind of low because of my pH, but you live and learn... buy decent test kits right off the bat and you'll end up saving yourself a lot of hassle and money in the long run.

This low alkalinity may explain why I've been having problems with hair algae for quite some time also. However, just to be on the "safe side" I installed a phosban reactor to try to make sure that phosphates (unreadable on the test kit) were not to blame. I slowly increased the dose because I've heard that adding a phosban reactor can have bad effects on SPS if you just dump a bunch in. I upped the dose slowly (1/4, 1/2, 3/4, full over about 6 weeks).

I was also worried I didn't have quite enough flow, so I popped off a few of my loc-line T's (which actually seemed to be reducing the flow quite a bit, although putting it out in a more controlled manner) and added a mj1200. Hopefully I can remove that once I get some penductors to put on the closed loop and return.

So, those are the major changes I've made and I feel pretty confident now that my water is ship-shape. The hair algae is certainly not growing as much as it used to and I think with the addition of a few more bluelegs and snails (haven't added any in quite some time) that the problem will deal with itself.

My only concern is that lately, a lot of the corals that have been doing good higher up in my tank are starting to look a little bleached out. A lot of the stuff is starting to get color it's never had before, but I've had to cycle quite a few of my SPS to lower parts of the tank because they are bleaching and having little polyp extension. This seems to fix them. I'm just curious if anyone has ever experienced an increased sensitivity to light associated with the changes I've made (which may be too numerous to seperate). Most of the corals that are bleaching I would consider lower light SPS (mostly different monti's), but I never had issues with them where they were before. Enlighten me wise ones... :)
 
Maybe with the increased water quality you are increasing the water clarity? The corals might be getting more light now.
 
I think it is hard to say with all of the changes that have been going on. One possibility is nutrients. Since you may have been feeding less due to the hair algae issue. I initially had too low nutrients, I think, and my SPS got mighty pale. I thought it was my lighting and moved things all over -- some placements seemed to do better than others. However, when I fed more (and fed the sps specifically by dumping in DTs oyster eggs, or Rotifeast a few times/week) the color came back.

That may not be your problem, but nutrients play a big part in coloration IME.
 
It also sounds to me like you have inceased the clarity. You might want to back off a little on the Phosban. Not sure how much it takes to fill a reactor up 3/4 full but that sounds like a lot. Most people that use it say it doen't take much at all. What are using for flow besides the return and powerhead? Not that's related to the bleaching but it could relate to the corals overall health over time.
Chris
 
Clarity may have something to do with it as mentioned above, but my best guess is that it has to do with the Phosban itself. I used to run it in the past and it continually led to STN and RTN. I wouldn't dare put the stuff in my tank anymore. I know there are alot of people that run it with sucess, but for some reason it just never worked for me.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9906739#post9906739 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by c_stowers
Clarity may have something to do with it as mentioned above, but my best guess is that it has to do with the Phosban itself. I used to run it in the past and it continually led to STN and RTN. I wouldn't dare put the stuff in my tank anymore. I know there are alot of people that run it with sucess, but for some reason it just never worked for me.

My sentiments exactly on Fe P removers but since most SPS keepers (at least in polls on RC) now run them with sucess I have backed off a little on recommending people not use them. If you start seeing STN/RTN I would definately quit but then it's usually too late for several corals.

Chris
 
Thanks for the input.

I just reread my post and wasn't clear about how much Phosban I am using. The fractions are fractions of the recommended dose... so I'm only running about 4 tablespoons, not a full reactor. That's a big difference :lol:

I really fought with myself over whether or not to use phosban, but I've been at my wits end with this hair algae issue and I felt like it was one of the only things I haven't tried. Also, I started seeing that a ton of people with SPS use it, so I figured it can't be all bad. I will definitely keep an eye on everything (as I have been) and consider getting rid of the phosban if anything keeps going downhill.

As far as flow, Chris, I'm running the Eheim 1262 that I got with your old set-up as the return and I installed a Gen-X PCX 40 on a closed loop that is very similar in design to the one I got with your set-up (I had to re-engineer part of it, but it's the same hang over the back type thing). I've been wanting to get penductors and am actually currently having my step-dad fashion me a few. If I am a little bit low on flow still, I'm hoping that that will fix my problems. I've heard they work quite nicely.
 
The penductors will help quite a bit. You may also find it usefull to add a powerhead here and there to help with dead spots. I allways seem to need a couple in addition to my CL's. The modded MJ 900's seem to work really well for the price and wattage used.
Chris
 
Not sure of the verdict on the Koralia pumps, I know they had some early issues, but Fostersmith has them pretty reasonable right now. I need to ditch some things in my tank making tons of heat and was concidering them in place of the seios.
 
I have to of the smaller koralia's and love them no issues at all, and my dad is running two of the larget ones and he loves them as welll.
 
Back
Top