Disaster. Everything is Dead. Help.

Patroklos

New member
Well, not everything.

So, I wake up on this fine morning, put on my uniform and head out for the day with the sun not even up yet. Upon walking past my darkened aquarium I notice there is some hazyness to the glass. I walk up to inspect and I can feel the heat radiating from the tank. I flip on a light, and am horrified. All my corals are melted, my shimps dead, and the water is a soup of coral slime and tissue debris.

I do a quick inspection of the hardware and instantly find the problem. The water temperature is 85 degrees. I keep it at 72 normally. I take a look at my heater controler and there it is, set to 73 with its "heating" light happily illuminated regardless.

Immediate actions? Ripped the heater out of the wall and smashed into a dozen pieces. I then dumped the contents of my freezer ice trays into the fuge. Before having to leave for work I had the temp down to 83. I turned off all the powerheads, and took my daytime lights offline for the day. My two prized corals, a 30+ head branching australian frogspawn and 6'' in diameter australian wall hammer coral, are a mass of none to slowely desitigrating ooze. My acans look like jelly.

Losses:
Branching Frogspawn - $150
Wall Hammer - $175
Rainbow Acans - $250
Cleaner Shrimp - $30
Fire Shrimp - $30

Probably Losses:
Elegance Coral - $125
Chalice Coral - $60
BTA - $70

Looking Good So Far:
Brain coral
Assorted Zoas/Palys
Bubble Coral
Pipe Organ
All Fish

So all told I am looking at a $890 bath. If I was going to waste that kind of money in one evening I would have prefered to have done so in a bar or brothel.

So now I am at work, helpless to do anything but think about my tank imploding (and murdering the manufacturers of that heater). Not that I could do much if I was at home but watch my favorite corals die.

Well, thats the story so far, what is the advice you guys have for containing this unmitigated disaster? I know I need to get that dead matter out of there, unfortunetly I did a 25% water change last night (what a waste) so I have no water. I plan on just using tap once I get home to do a 50%, whatever is in the tap water can't be worse that what floating in my tank now. I anticipate an algea bloom, but there isn't much I can do about that. I hope the temperature has dropped by the time I get home, but if not I will continue dropping in ice until it has. I am really at a loss...
 
that really does suck! but why in gods name are you running a reef at 72? but that probaly wouldn't have matter if the heater stuck on anyways.
that sucks
 
Wow...so sorry to hear about that man, what a nightmare. How large is your system? Running a skimmer? What type? I suppose you could point a fan over the surface of the tank to help cool it down as well?

I don't know about the tap water though...no way for you to get some RO/DI at a LFS or grocery store somewhere? with as much stress as your system has just taken, dumping tap water into it might harm those things that are still hanging on
 
Sorry about your loss. I run both my tanks at 80 deg. A few weeks ago I was cleaning my 55g and didn't realize that I moved the temp probe up and almost out of the water. Just by accident I noticed later in the day that the temp was 85. I too pulled the heater and turned on all my fans. Within 30mins the temp was back to 80 with no loses. Thank goodness.
 
but why in gods name are you running a reef at 72?

That is just the temperature things settled at when I was setting things up. I tried maintaining it up to 75-76 but its been at 72 for a good 6 months and everything was happy, so I let things be.

I am sort of confused why the melt down was so quick. I hear plenty of people keep there tanks at 80-81. I guess the swing was too sudden.
 
Wow...so sorry to hear about that man, what a nightmare. How large is your system? Running a skimmer? What type? I suppose you could point a fan over the surface of the tank to help cool it down as well?

65gal, Octopus 110nw skimmer. I didn't have time to set up the fan before heading to work, if it isn't down when I head back during lunch I will do exactly that.

I don't know about the tap water though...no way for you to get some RO/DI at a LFS or grocery store somewhere? with as much stress as your system has just taken, dumping tap water into it might harm those things that are still hanging on

I could probably get distilled water at the grocery store, how much does that run for?
 
you can get distilled water from wal-mart for like 50-60 cents a gallon, and its label states that it is processed by ro, carbon, ozone, and distilation. that is what i used exclusively until i got my 6 stage ro/di, and be cause my lfs sold me some ro/di that was yellow tinted so i didn't trust it. and they sell it in 3 gallon boxes.
 
I might have to hit them up then. I can probably make ten gallons today with my 6 stage, I'll supplement that with bought RO then. Thanks.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14679400#post14679400 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Patroklos
That is just the temperature things settled at when I was setting things up. I tried maintaining it up to 75-76 but its been at 72 for a good 6 months and everything was happy, so I let things be.

I am sort of confused why the melt down was so quick. I hear plenty of people keep there tanks at 80-81. I guess the swing was too sudden.

Yeah I am pretty sure it was the swing in temp that did the corals in
 
+1 on the temperature swing. Most corals should be able to take 85 degrees. Another testimony to keeping two heaters at 1/2 the needed wattage rather than one.....three heaters for the truly paranoid like myself.
 
sorry for your loss.

Like somebody else posted above, I highly recommend a Ranco temp controller and a titanium heating element without a controller, just let the ranco do it. I've never heard of anybody who had a ranco fail on them. theyre industrial built to last.

I've used multiple different brands of heaters that have the onboard thermostat and EVERY SINGLE ONE always drifts or malfunctions in some way after only a few months. Now all I use those kind of heaters for is heating up fresh saltwater for waterchanges. Its so worth the money for the ranco.
 
also the ranco lets you set the hysteresis, so you can build in a temperature swing. Its long been known that corals that are kept at a constant temperature 100% of the time will not be able to tolerate relatively small temperature swings compared to corals that live in a constant state of temp swing.

I let my temp go between 77-81. Not a huge swing but its pretty natural IMO. actually its a small swing compared to nature but I feel its important.
 
75 is too cool for a reef, IMO. a normal tropical reef likely sees temps of 85 or so pretty frequently.......you should keep it between 78-82 or so. Some keep theirs as high as 83 on a daily basis.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14679666#post14679666 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by ReefEnabler
sorry for your loss.

Like somebody else posted above, I highly recommend a Ranco temp controller and a titanium heating element without a controller, just let the ranco do it. I've never heard of anybody who had a ranco fail on them. theyre industrial built to last.


Heaters are disasters waiting to happen. If you want to minimize your livestock risk, get a ranco.
 
Back
Top