Don't use iodine daily

Paul, what did that quart of Lugols set you back 20 years ago?
Did you buy it at Sam's Club? Was there a Sam's Club back then? LOL

Just a little comic relief. This thread has been an interesting read.
It's your tank. Do whatever works for ya.
 
bitis its fine to do iodine daily. if you adjust the ammount to match the coral intake.. in fact id recomend diluting hte lugals you dose every day and add 1/10th of it every day
this way you keep a constant level instead of having it yoyo

same with ca and alk additives
instead of 500 then 450 then 400 then 500 again you have 500 then 490 then 500 ppm ( or what ever )


and why are you dosing everything when allyou need is c balance.. or since it looks liek mostly softies... essential elements iodine and a rare does of c balance..

what is you CA and alk at. i have a feeling it is falling out of solution and not being utilized
 
Paul, what did that quart of Lugols set you back 20 years ago?

I don't remember but I know I split the cost with a LFS. I got it in a drug store. I don't even know what Sams Club is. I think it was about $20.00 and I still have more than half of it left.
Paul
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8501368#post8501368 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by goda
bitis its fine to do iodine daily. if you adjust the ammount to match the coral intake..


and how do you do this? do you know how much corals use or if corals even need it? how do you test it? what's the overdose amount? etc. etc. iodine is a halogen just like chlorine and burns at to high a dosage just like chlorine.
after spending a few years dosing it and many more not dosing it, I'll stick to not dosing. I've seen absolutely no difference and my xenia is still a weed and my caps grow a 1/2"+ a month.

YMMV if you don't do any water changes for two and a half years... ;) :D
 
I don;t dose daily with iodine....Once every 7-10-14 or when ever i feel like I add a couple drops of lugols....It's not that big of a deal....I don't even test my levels.....My stuff just stays right...I have been doing the same thing for so long, and learning from my family...I'll stick with what works for me....It's aparently good enough for 60 species or so to replicate.....And good enough for my family to continue making a living....It's work for me....Probably not for everyone..I just no my systems... I know by looking when one of my tanks needs something...Thanks for all the imput though..Good luck to everyone in the future.....Keep it up to save the reefs..........
 
I was drunk, I apologize to anyone I offended with my novella. I stand by the gist of my post. Usually I just ignore people who poo poo something someone else is doing but since I was a potential target and I'd had a good night at the local bar. I couldn't help myself. Unfortunately I wasn't very professional.

On a different track, in line with this post there are even people who dose with Vodka. Ethanol. The reasons for this would take another novella to post for. To each his or her own.

According to information I have, natural seawater has iodine in various forms at a rough concentration of 0.06 ppm. (460 nmol/kg) If your anywhere near that your probably golden as long as it's in a form the corals can use.

If you feed your corals well, they probably are happy little pigs and get all the Iodine they would ever need from the food. Freshwater top offs, plus regular water changes, should easily replace any lost. If your shrimp and crabs are dying when they molt. Or if your Xenia or Gorgonians are having some issues you may wish to take a look at your Iodine levels. If your corals have bleached or are in the process of bleaching you may wish to dose with Iodine/lugols (per manufacturers instructions). Iodine loss isn't the result of the bleaching but is used to lessen the severity of coral bleaching and helps the coral's Xooxanthellae to recover much quicker.

Overdosing would be tragic. If you choose to supplement Iodine, stay close to the manufacturers suggested dosage unless you intend to experiment.

I hope this post restates my position without being an *** about it.

Tallinu
 
Back
Top