effects of high silicate

I am not totally convinced this is a fungus as the fungus medication I used actually made it grow at an accelerated rate.

I just checked my Nitrate again (I haven't checked it lately) and it couldn't be any lower on my LaMotte test kit. If I didn't know any better I would say it is in the negatives :)
 
Last edited:
Chris,
Glad to hear you making head way on that crap.... When did you get that rock. I have heard the some of the older base rock like you have was high in phoshate and leaching. I think we need to make a club buy and get a Colorimeter. I would love to know where mine stands too.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14939371#post14939371 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by mixer911
Chris,
Glad to hear you making head way on that crap.... When did you get that rock. I have heard the some of the older base rock like you have was high in phoshate and leaching. I think we need to make a club buy and get a Colorimeter. I would love to know where mine stands too.
Click to expand...

Hey Rick!

I was hoping to come by and check out your setup sometime soon. You busy tomorrow? I have to cruise to franklin and could come back 840 and stop by murfreesboro. Send me a pm if that sounds cool.

I am going to get some pics going tonight at some point if I have time.

I bought that rock from a company called Reefer Rocks (No longer in business when business was booming for them....hmmmmmm) years ago probably about 3 to be exact. The ghost algae started about that time. Before that my tank looked pretty good. Not great but everything was healthy. I asked whether I should cook it and was told no just throw it in.

I have 3 things on my list to purchase and no cash for any of them :p . A colorometer, a tunze osmolator, and a i-Tech 100 or 200 skimmer.

Also it may be too soon to know but I am wondering if it is possible that the algaefix may kill red flatworms and redbugs? After the frag swap I received both :eek1: as my father was in the hospital (fell the day before and broke his hip) and I just didn't have time to dip them. I felt my Dad was more important than the tank. The only reason I went is because Fishdoc11 had already cut me some frags and I felt obligated.

Anyways since adding the algaefix I haven't seen either and I have been looking for them.
 
Last edited:
Im glad I found this thread! I recently seen I have some clear slimy stuff growin in my reef, it seems to stick to plastic so far (with fingers crossed) And I have some floating in the low current parts of my fuge.

The stuff on my return hoses looks to be the same as what you have CeeGee, but I wonder if the stuff floating in my fuge is the same, they both showed up at the same time, I assumed they were the same

I was thinking a bacteria of some sort, but on the returns it sticks pretty good.

IMG_1685.jpg


IMG_1688.jpg
 
mi casa is su casa! anytime man! i will shoot you a pm!!!

Bri guy, is that a tooth brush!! you need ghost busters, :lol:
 
Bri Guy,

It looks to be the same pest to me.

One way to tell if it is a fungus or bacterium, according to Boomer, is to take a sample of this pest out and apply some Methyl blue to it. If it stains with the Methyl blue, then it is a _____________? I can't remember which stains with the Methyl Blue, Perhaps Boomer can chime in. I can't find the thread that Boomer posted this information in. :(
 
It is not Fungus. All of that suff you guys are seeing is not fungus but a bacterial growth. Fungus is, very, very rare in seawater. If you leave a dead fish in the tank long enough and it turns fuzzy, that is fungus, not this stuff.

I am not totally convinced this is a fungus as the fungus medication I used actually made it grow at an accelerated rate.

That means nothing as allot of the so called "fungus" is not fungus at all but bacteria that mimics an appearance of fungus. For decades people have had a bad habit, to include drug people, to call it fungus if it is fuzzy like which is not an ID. What is the med ? If the fungus med made it accelerate why would it be a fungus? You have that backwards. The drug is probably fueling the bacteria to grow.
 
A bacteria would mean that carbon dosing is actually perpetuating the problem. Maybe those of us that are carbon dosing should quit and try some gfo.
 
Many have tried that too without success. Bacteria can derive their food directly from the fish food before it has a chance of braking down. I don't think you will be able to starve the bacteria to death without killing everything else in your tank first. I am not saying reducing your nitrate, phosphate and organics will not help. ;)
 
This is the reason that I really hope that the AlgaeFix can completely eradicate this bacterial pest. If you don't eradicate it, it will multiply quickly and you will be back to where you started from in no time. Sorry to say that a bacterial pest is more difficult to get rid of than the cyanobacteria which need light to survive in many cases. :(
 
If anyone is near a university I can say with a high degree of certainty that a Marine/Micro/Molecular Biologist would not mind throwing a sample of this under a nice microscope to help get a decent ID. I would suggest looking at the online course catalogs to find a proper teacher to contact before showing up though!
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14942487#post14942487 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Boomer
It is not Fungus. All of that suff you guys are seeing is not fungus but a bacterial growth. Fungus is, very, very rare in seawater. If you leave a dead fish in the tank long enough and it turns fuzzy, that is fungus, not this stuff.

If the fungus med made it accelerate why would it be a fungus? You have that backwards. The drug is probably fueling the bacteria to grow.
Click to expand...


If you read what I wrote I said that I don't think it is a fungus so I don't have anything backwards as far as I can tell. It was mention by Cliff that it may be a fungus as it has no chlorophyl. I don't really care what it is I just want it to go away :)

If I had to wager I would say that my carbon source and bacteria that I am adding is what is helping the most. The algaefix seems to have hit a wall for lack of a better term. I keep adding it like the bottle says but it isn't driving the final nail into the coffin.
 
CeeGee,

Yes, I was the culprit that mentioned it looks like a fungus to me. It will not be the last time Boomer comes down on me either. :lol:

I would stop dosing the carbon source and give it about a week. Then I would try squirting some diluted AlgaeFix (diluted with your tank water) directly on this pest. If this does not work, I would then try stop feeding your fish for a least three days and hit it with the AlgaeFix at that point. I can't come up with anything else at this point to try. :(
 
The tank is in much better shape at the moment than it has been in a long time. Corals aren't real happy but I attribute that to the algaefix. I remembered on my last tank (where this stuff was incredibly bad) when I began the carbon source and bacteria after about 6 weeks into it I could blow this stuff off my frag rack with a turkey baster easily. So it was working albeit slowly.

For the time being I am going to continue doing what I am doing as it is working. I think if I were just using a carbon source I would be in real trouble but I am also dosing bacteria that helps to keep one type (this bad stuff) from taking over. It keeps it varied.

This is very similar to what SunnyX is doing with his tank. He started dosing vodka and had a algae bloom. He stopped dosing the vodka and started dosing bacteria (to keep it varied and preventing the bad stuff from outcompeting the others) and then restarted the vodka and it works. You just have to keep the bacteria "multi-cultural" if you will.

The one clue that lets me know something is definitely working is the fact that I was able to scrub this stuff of my frag plugs with a toothbrush this weekend. Before this stuff would have laughed at a toothbrush. I will get some pics tonight so you can see the difference.
 
Last edited:
CeeGee,

It sounds to me that you have a good grip about the processes going on regarding this pest. Your plan sounds good to me. :thumbsup:

Please keep us posted. I would like to see a control measure developed for this particular pest, since it seems to show up every now and then. :(
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14948028#post14948028 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by HighlandReefer
CeeGee,

It sounds to me that you have a good grip about the processes going on regarding this pest. Your plan sounds good to me. :thumbsup:

Please keep us posted. I would like to see a control measure developed for this particular pest, since it seems to show up every now and then. :(
Click to expand...

Several of our club members have it. I think it is more common than it seems. It seems to take hold on some peoples tanks (like mine) and not others for some reason.

I wouldn't say that I have a good grip, I would say I have been given good advice. Once again this board is invaluable. All in all this has been a result of extremely bad advice of my LFS and my inexperience in reefkeeping.

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14948911#post14948911 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by gdm42001
CeeGee,
What is this Bacteria you are dosing?
Click to expand...
Polyp Labs-Genesis Other companies make similar products. Prodibio has something similar as does Brightwell. I think their version is called MicroBacter7.
 
Last edited:
As promised here are a couple of pics.


This is one of the frag plugs from the previous pics. It was by far the worst of the bunch. It was really hairy.
almostgone_1.jpg


The same plug from the top. The top was completely covered and begining to kill this coral.
almostgone_2.jpg


This rock was getting pretty wicked with this stuff. It is all but gone. If I hit it with a toothbrush (this weekend during WC) I will eraditcate what is left. Notice the Birdsnest is starting to get some color back. It looked dead it bleached so badly. I really think this stuff poisons the tank in some form or another.
almostgone_3.jpg


Believe it or not there is a little tissue left here. I circled it in a transparent red. This was completely covered in tissue in january. This was the second worst frag plug. It looked like a hairy tree limb a couple weeks ago. This bacteria as we are now calling it nearly killed this frag. I am hoping it will bounce back.
almostgone_4.jpg


As you can see things are a little better :) Also of note is the eggcrate frag rack. It was hairy a few weeks ago. No more :)

I am not out of the woods yet and I still may end up chucking this rock, bleaching tank and equipment and basically starting over. I am going to give it more time though first.

I can't stress enough how tough this stuff is. The remainder of my rock has been cooking since January 3rd and it is still not completely clean. This is nasty stuff.
 
quote:Originally posted by gdm42001 CeeGee, What is this Bacteria you are dosing? Polyp Labs-Genesis Other companies make similar products. Prodibio has something similar as does Brightwell. I think their version is called MicroBacter7.
Click to expand...

Anything in particular draw you to the Polyp Labs-Genesis rather than the others?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

R
How is my chemistry looking?
Replies
2
Views
238
ReefKG
ReefKG
G
Porifera identification
Replies
5
Views
424
griss
griss
griss
Citric Acid
Replies
10
Views
408
griss
griss
griss
High pH / Low Alk
Replies
6
Views
2K
griss
griss
C
Can’t keep overflow box balanced
Replies
2
Views
159
Cruzersmith
C
Back
Top