It sounds like you don't get up North or East often, but Pets Plus in Lockport is a great store and also The Fish Place at 141 Robinson St. in North Tonawanda. I know that was not what you asked, but I spend most of my week in Erie and Buffalo and I have not found anything in Erie yet. Also, if you get out by Batavia, there is Pet Mart which has a great selection of equipment but is a little light on live stock. They are in the process of building a new fish room, though.