Fed up with my Zoanthids and palys

oldss72

New member
Hello,

I recently moved (3 months ago). After moving my tank, I was obviously distracted with my new house, and my tank suffered a bit for it. After a month in the new house, I noticed some excess hair algae and red slime. I used red slime remover, changed the water exactly as the directions tell, and that helped with the red slime. I picked out the hair algae, and have been much better with water changes. I also noticed the extra sunlight that was hitting the tank, and tried to be diligent to close the drapes to prevent the hair algae. All this time, NONE of my corals seemed worse for the wear. I have in the tank and open brain coral, some candy canes, a plate coral, xenia, various mushrooms, and my z's and p's. I noticed about 2 months ago, that my button polyps were not extending, all 3 colonies. I thought nothing of it since my water seemed to always test fine. After another 2 weeks all my zonathids closed up for good as well. Since then, they have not opened at all!.

I have not had any melt away like they were dying, and in the past ~2 months, they all just stay fully closed. I also cannot prevent some small amounts of hair algae from growing on these guys. I do water changes, dose Calcium and alk, test all my parameters, and everything seems to be ok. I have done dips in coral revive, Iodine dips, even tried hydrogen peroxide at the suggestion of my local salt water store (only 1 button polyp colony). I have not seen any nudibranch's, nor any other pests in my dips. I also do not have any fish that would be nipping at them to keep them closed. All were in my tank for ~1 year before this issue, and were always open and happy.

Can anyone suggest anything to check? I know water temp is constant at 76, my salinity is always ~1.025-1.0255. I checked my hydrometer with my LFS, and it is in line with their water.

Thanks in advance
 
Temp should be about 79F or 80F.
"Salinity" about 1.023 to 1.025 is good.

Please tell us what are the alk, calcium and so on, if you can...

Seems like your system had a shock while moving, than you left it alone and the problem got worse. It is very important to pay attention to the tank while and after moving it.
I believe the best to do is to bring the temp SLOWLY to 79F. Than watch the chemistry and perform 5 to 10% partial water changes very carefuly every 2 weeks, if needed.
Try to find out what else that could be.
Did you use all new syntetic water after the moving? If so, that could be it. Besides that the temperature fluctuation with the air exposure could do it too.
Can be lots of things...
After the shock the zoas can take a while to show you the damage done.
More info would be great, so people can try to help you...
Good luck,
Grandis
 
Is yours a swing-arm hydrometer? Those aren't always the most accurate, no matter how you cross check them... Make sure they're getting good flow and +1 on bumping up the temp.
 
Get a refractometer to get better readings on the SG and if your LFS did not tell you, they likely are not great to go to for advice...
 
Back
Top