<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=9184801#post9184801 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by robthorn
well no offense but that type of chiller idea sounds bad. I could be misunderstanding you though. if you are going to run all the tanks together why not make them all the same water and chill everything with one chiller if you need it. i forget do you have halides? if not you should be able to do it without a chiller easy.
Here is a hypothetical the set up...
Tank A - Shrooms
Tank B - Singulara
Tank C - Zoa
Tank D - SPS
If I plum them all to a common sump and chill the sump, it is easier, true, BUT I have to deal with the fact that I am no longer species specific and will have reduce growth rates, cross contamination, a death in one tank hurting the others...etc.
IF I set up a 55 barrel place the chiller in that and then run a Closed loop though all 4 tanks through heat exchangers in each tank including the 55 barrel I will create a system that is making the temp in all 4 tanks consistent. When the collective tank temp rises to high, the chiller kicks on directly cooling the 55 and indirectly cooling all 4 tanks.
This gives me the benefit of a chiller chilled system and the need to only run a single chiller. This also give me the benefit of having species specific systems. this allows me to isolate as many variables as possible all while maximizing the potential growth rates in my tanks. It also mitigates the possible loss from contamination of a system crash.
all in all, from my perspective, the system looks like it could be very effective and quite simple, once built.
The cost issues are the cost of the heat exchangers, the 2 pumps needed for chilling, although I could reduce it to 1 If I plumb it right (by eliminating the 55 and crating a single closed loop), and the actual AC/coper costs of the Split unit design.
This is something that I am going to consider and begin to research, it may just prove to be a decent solution to my situation.
Let me work on a drawing at lunch, that may help us visualize what I am thinking.