I have been impressed with Exotic Aquatics both times I was there. TFP has a much better dry goods selection and price, but EAs selection of SPS, LPS, soft, etc. seemed great to me. As I have mentioned in other posts my only complaint there is that most of their corals dont have prices on the tanks... the person I spoke to said they were tying to get a handle on that problem as well. regardless, the things that I asked about there were fairly priced and looked healthy, but were not at bargain prices. when I was there they had colorful zoo frags (~10-20 polyps) for $30-40, mounted monti cap frags for ~40-60, and colorful mounted SPS colonys for ~60 with buy 1 get one at a discount... I thought it was fair pricing, but I have been buying my stock lately from fellow reefers....
I havent been to the new hidden reef yet- I am waiting untill they get livestock as I cant imagine they will beat TFP on dry...
For numerous reasons I wont detail here I no longer shop at ECA-- but in brief, TFP beats them on dry goods. their livestock looks to be of good quality, but I wont pay their price to find out for sure...