Hardiness of Resplendent/Tierra Anthias?

holdyourlight

New member
Anyone have issues keeping these?

I bought a pair from BZ a couple months ago

Ate like pigs then all of a sudden stopped eating and died within a couple weeks of each other.

No issues with any other fishes in the tank
 
PE Mysis, spectrum and rod's food

I only fed once a day, but i started off feeding more and then weened it to once a day

They did not seem skinny at all
 
Anthias need many feedings per day in my experience. Because they are not the biggest or most aggressive fish in most tanks, they usually do not eat much at feeding time, so multiple feedings usually help. There is a public aquarium in SF that houses an Anthias tank that has a constant drip of food so the anthias always have something to nibble on!

I've got 4 Resplendents and while 3 are now male, they are gorgeous and get along pretty good! I"ll be adding another 6 females soon!
 
Anthias need many feedings per day in my experience. Because they are not the biggest or most aggressive fish in most tanks, they usually do not eat much at feeding time, so multiple feedings usually help. There is a public aquarium in SF that houses an Anthias tank that has a constant drip of food so the anthias always have something to nibble on!

I've got 4 Resplendents and while 3 are now male, they are gorgeous and get along pretty good! I"ll be adding another 6 females soon!

Wow can't believe 3 of the 4 turned male
One of mine already looked like she was turning
I think they are prettier as females
 
Mine definitely have some that are turning. On the other hand I feed three to four times daily: Black worms, fish roe, mysis (both kinds). I suspect you were not feeding sufficiently.
 
I've seen perfectly healthy, well established anthias just one day stop eating. It must be a pathogen of some sort. I just have no clue what it is. I liken it to a severe flu. It happened to several of my anthias recently. I only lost a couple though, and the rest recovered. IME insufficient feeding of anthias doesn't cause them to stop eating, at least not without clear physical signs of emaciation first.
 
Listen to Peter as he has forgotten more than I currently know about anthias. :love1:

no doubt!!

wonder if i should try Randall's next time because the females look exactly the same

i wonder if they are less apt to change over to males as it seems resplendents are
 
I haven't found it to be a function of the species. I've had it happen to bartletts and lyretails before. My friend and I refer to it as the "swimming dead"...
 
Could someone please post a pic of their resplendents? I'm trying to decide on a school of anthias for my 180g and am currently looking at resplendents and carberryi. The pics I find on-line and in books vary greatly so I'm not sure what these fish actually look like.
 
A few weeks after I got my trio of P. Dispars, one of the females stopped eating and stopped swimming, she just perched on a piece of live rock for about 5 days. After the 5th or 6th day, I decided to remove her, so I placed her in a small "kritter keeper" with an airstone and piece of rock and treated her with Maracyn. After a week of treatment, she was placed back in the QT with the other 2. I have no idea what the problem was, or if it was even the treatment that helped (couldve just been the week alone that helped) but she starting eating again and acted normal from then on. I have no idea if this has any relavence to the OP's problem, but it's worth a shot if anyone else finds themselves in that situation.
 
I haven't found it to be a function of the species. I've had it happen to bartletts and lyretails before. My friend and I refer to it as the "swimming dead"...

swimming dead!!

this is exactly what i saw happen just hovering there instead of swimming around
 
Could someone please post a pic of their resplendents? I'm trying to decide on a school of anthias for my 180g and am currently looking at resplendents and carberryi. The pics I find on-line and in books vary greatly so I'm not sure what these fish actually look like.


24.jpg


23.jpg


16.jpg


17.jpg
 
How can you recognize this condition? What can be done about it (if anything)?

Well, some of this is going to sound strange, but here goes. I'll use my most recent experience as an example. Most of my anthias are a few years old. Even the newest ones are over a year old. Nothing new, no finicky eaters. One night I feed them, everything is normal, they eat like pigs, and they are acting "normal". With respect to how they act - it's tough to describe, but you just know, after watching these fish day in and day out, for years, what "normal acting" is... know what I mean?

Well, the next day I get home from work and immediately know something is wrong. I don't see all the anthias swimming around as usual, and they certainly don't all flutter up to the water surface when they see me approach the tank. Three dispars, a carberryi, and a lyretail are either missing, or just perched on a rock, or wedged in a corner of the tank.

These "sick" fish look perfect, physically. Not a mark or blemish on them. Well fed, not at all skinny. The other fish, even the other anthias, pay them zero attention. They are from all levels in the hierarchy. The lyretail is the male, the dispars consist of the male, a medium female, and the lowest level female. The carberryi (only one in the tank) is larger than all but the lyretail. A couple things you do notice about them... their eyes don't move around very much, like healthy anthias. They just have this glassy stare (I know it sounds weird, but that's the impression I get). If you try to catch them, they will move, but only after you are practically already touching them, and even then it's just a short move to a new perch. Nothing like the darting of a healthy anthias ducking for cover. They will not eat.

Fast forward several weeks... and this is the first time this has happened for me. Two of the dispars and the carberryi start swimming around a bit. They sort of go for food...but they often miss it. Like they are drunk. They sometimes swim into rocks or other objects. After several more weeks they begin to eat well, and after a few months have made a full recovery. The lyretail and the third dispar just continued to perch, for weeks and weeks, until they were skinny enough/weak enough to simply catch with a net. The entire time, they never, ever had a physical mark on them, and strangely were never ever bothered by any of the other anthias.

This is not the first time this has happened to anthias in my tank, and a friend of mine has also seen this happen in his tank.

So... told you this would sound weird :)
 
No idea. It's obviously a pathogen, but what it is, I have no clue. So I have no idea how to treat. Like I said, it's as if they catch a really bad cold or flu :) Also, since they aren't eating, they cannot be trapped and removed. I'm afraid by the time they are "catchable" they are pretty far gone.
 
Back
Top