Help! My parameters are fine but everything seems to be dying!

I have it so the pumps kind of circulate around rhe tank faced at the glass and the return is putting out around 400 gph I would say.

How big is your tank? You'll need anywhere from 20-40 times turnover per hour depending on the corals you keep and some SPS need even higher. Like my tank which is a 75-gallon for 20x It would be 1500gph 40x would obviously mean 3000gph.
 
How big is your tank? You'll need anywhere from 20-40 times turnover per hour depending on the corals you keep and some SPS need even higher. Like my tank which is a 75-gallon for 20x It would be 1500gph 40x would obviously mean 3000gph.

Are you talking turnover rate thru the sump? If so, this would scare many people away. You probably mean 20 to 40 times turnover total water movement. Just wanted to clarify that so he doesn't go out and get a massive energy hogging pump he doesn't need.

The main thing has already been said...stability. A reef tank will run better at poor parameters that are constant and steady better than one who has perfect, then not so perfect, then perfect, then not so perfect.

Salinity changes are by far the easiest of all the parameters to keep constant. So figure that out and your probably going to be good to go.

Keep your water changes spaced out evenly. Don't do one this week, 2 next week, then wait a month and do a big change because its been a while. Keep it scheduled. Not saying that's what you doing, but just a thought to keep in mind for the future.

Try taking your filter sock off if you remove your sump sand. Unless you change that out every other other day, it's not helping. Even then some will say not to use one.

Do you have a regular thermometer? If that sticker one is old, it could be off.

Take that sand out of your sump. Doesn't look clean. Trapping all kinds of junk down there. That will only help you situation. Use that space as a settling chamber to get rid of detritus. That sounded kind of mean...sorry. not trying to be. Just trying to help so you don't get frustrated and give up.
 
Last edited:
Are you talking turnover rate thru the sump? If so, this would scare many people away. You probably mean 20 to 40 times turnover total water movement. Just wanted to clarify that so he doesn't go out and get a massive energy hogging pump he doesn't need.

The main thing has already been said...stability. A reef tank will run better at poor parameters that are constant and steady better than one who has perfect, then not so perfect, then perfect, then not so perfect.

Salinity changes are by far the easiest of all the parameters to keep constant. So figure that out and your probably going to be good to go.

Keep your water changes spaced out evenly. Don't do one this week, 2 next week, then wait a month and do a big change because its been a while. Keep it scheduled. Not saying that's what you doing, but just a thought to keep in mind for the future.

Try taking your filter sock off if you remove your sump sand. Unless you change that out every other other day, it's not helping. Even then some will say not to use one.

Do you have a regular thermometer? If that sticker one is old, it could be off.

Take that sand out of your sump. Doesn't look clean. Trapping all kinds of junk down there. That will only help you situation. Use that space as a settling chamber to get rid of detritus. That sounded kind of mean...sorry. not trying to be. Just trying to help so you don't get frustrated and give up.

Haha its fine I don't even know where you sounded mean. That sand is actually this crappy refugium mineral mud since I couldn't find any Miracle Mud to save my life. Everything stuck in it is old chaeto.
 
Are you talking turnover rate thru the sump? If so, this would scare many people away. You probably mean 20 to 40 times turnover total water movement. Just wanted to clarify that so he doesn't go out and get a massive energy hogging pump he doesn't need.

Clearly, I wasn't talking about sump turnover. I probably should have clarified that but most people that have been in the hobby know sump turnover and inside the tank circulation are two different things.
 
What experienced people think is obvious is quite often not so obvious to someone new. The other day, I talked to a guy at work who has had a saltwater tank set up for 2 years. Found out he tops off with salt water. Its really amazing how many people start off doing this. So I explained salt doesn't evaporate. He didn't know what an auto top off was either.
I'll ask him at work Monday what his turnover rate is. Pretty sure his response will be "what do you mean?".
 
Last edited:
Back
Top