Hey guys, need advice/help plz

TitanCi

In Memoriam
Today marks day 12 of CP tx. Unfortunately, my sohal has been flashing for the past few days as well as the blenny... This morning the sohal is covered in ich.

Let's back track, so I can get the best, appropriate help.

The two culprits are the sohal and purple. Bought before Xmas, probably a week and a half. I was upgrading my tank, so all fish were in holding bins. I had an established yellow tang, so the tangs were together in a bin. When all appeared well, in went the fish. The next day or two the tangs showed signs of ich. Then the blenny. My clowns, nothing, wrasse, nothing. Some anthias were bought, and put into the holding bins and water where the tangs were, the purchase of the anthias and the transfer of the tangs happened within a day or so, the event s overlap.

On Xmas day I removed all fish from the tank and into bins they went. Ordered CP and began tx on 1/3/15.

1/6- ich appeared on the tangs, no serious effects, went away, thus at least 7-10 days elapsed before signs showed from first noticing.

1/11- sohal and blenny flash, blenny curls up and bites its tail. No other fish exhibit symptoms, but notice marks that may be ich on the yellow, some discoloration on the purple, but not sure if these were wounds from previous bout.

Naso shows some marks on body, more apparent on fins.

Yesterday prazipro was added, I thought it would be safe to add it at this point seeing how it was past the ten day mark, and I have the clowns and anthias in a separate tank. The tangs, blenny, and small wrasse are in a 40 breeder, and the clowns and anthias are in a separate 7 gallon.

1/15- this am, the sohal has spots all over fin, face, body; Naso: fins and round lesions on under belly, purple: white spots on fins, few spots on body, yellow difficult to tell but I think it has some. Blenny: no spots, but flashes. The clowns and anthias, at one point in the same tank as the other fish, have never showed signs of ich.

With each water change, I dosed the wc water with the appropriate cp from ebay.

At this point I am at a loss of words..

Is the ich just completing the life cycle and this happens to be coincidental? Or is cp failing? It appears the life cycle appeared every 10-12 days, and this is the worst I've seen the sohal.

Should I abandon cp and do ttm? I've done enough water changes where I should have just done ttm to begin with. I'm very upset at myself, and need guidance. Please advise! Thanks for reading
 
^i knew you'd say that Steve. I have 18 gallon bins. Two of them. Should that be sufficient for 4 tangs and the two smaller fish?
 
^i knew you'd say that Steve. I have 18 gallon bins. Two of them. Should that be sufficient for 4 tangs and the two smaller fish?

I would get a few more of them. By the way, it would be very helpful for us if you filled out your profile with regard to tank size, and actual experience. "Not a beginner" is just not descriptive enough. When we try to help it is very useful information for us with regard to actual time and experience with salt water. Since you do not quarantine, I assume you have not been doing this very long. Thanks. By helping us, you will allow us to more appropriately help you.
 
I would get a few more of them. By the way, it would be very helpful for us if you filled out your profile with regard to tank size, and actual experience. "Not a beginner" is just not descriptive enough. When we try to help it is very useful information for us with regard to actual time and experience with salt water. Since you do not quarantine, I assume you have not been doing this very long. Thanks. By helping us, you will allow us to more appropriately help you.


I usually never fill those out.. :)

I've been doing salt water since 2004, been fortunate not to be in this situation in years prior. And no, never qt til now.
 
Read up on tank transfer. Get at least one bin set for each tang. Leave your display tank fallow for 72 days.
 
Ah, and I usually never help those who do not fill those out. ;)


Well, luckily for me, you have been helping me. Im using tapatalk, to be fair, this isn't the easiest thing to navigate and update profiles and such as i haven't found it. :)
 
Ok. Your tank size and maturity?


I must point out, I am the same user as jbvdhp, and I don't understand why it doesn't load that profile. It seems to load my generic tapatalk info. That account was created in 2005 on rc.

My tank was upgraded from a 70 to a 125 gallon,6' so all the live rock was well cycled. New water was used as was new sand during the transfer. Inverts, corals, all the same from previous tank. The 70 gallon was up and running since 2005. The fish in it were at least a year old, the oldest ones being the tang, clowns, being 3-4 years old.

The variables were the two new tangs. And anthias. However, the anthias never made it to the dt.
 
I assume that you already know that a 125 gallon tank is way too small for four tangs, especially those four. After you do tank transfer, you will need a place to keep those fish to allow the DT to remain fishless for 72 days. I do not know about the double user issue, I will ask one of the mods to check it out.
 
Yes steve, i get the whole tang issue :), but tangs aside though... At this point my obvious goal is to cute their ailment. And quickly as I don't want to lose any fish.
 
Back
Top