I Give Up!!!

Lots of good advice here, you just need to put it all together.

Scrubbing your rock is a good way to get rid of the algae you have in your tank right now, but will not solve the problem long term. There will always be a little bit of algae in your system, and with the elevated nutrient levels in our systems, they will come back quickly.

The only contributor to algae in the tank is the food (ie: nutrients) we put into our tanks. No organism can completely digest what it eats so we end up with stuff like nitrates and phosphates in the water. This in turn feeds the algae.

Something you need to get used to is that you will have algae growing in your tank no matter what. The nutrients we have in out tanks, even with water changes are hundreds of times what they are on coral reefs, even in higher nutrient areas of the ocean. There have been open ocean experiments done showing that algaes will bloom at nutrient levels much lower than any hobbyist test kit can test for.

Algae makes up some 70 percent of the biomass of coral reefs. The thing is, that it is continually grazed by a huge population of herbivours from snails to large fish.

So, the issue is, how are you going to control the algaes in your tank? As others have mentioned, nasarious are carrion eaters so they are no help. It is a good idea to have a decent population of proper algae grazing snails such as astreas or turbos.

A lot of people also use macro algaes to compete with their more ugly bretheren. It will take a while for macro algaes to dominate.

Diedema urchins will eat pretty much any algae, but get large very quickly.

Find youself some good grazing snails, keep doing water changes and add some macro algae and you should get things under control. Do keep in mind that it will take a while. Long term changes in a tank always take a while.

Good luck.

Fred

P.S. you still need to harvest your macro algaes to export nutrients.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't put an urchin in a tank with two seahorses. Pencil urchins are less of a threat, but I would avoid anything else.
 
I have gone through so many astrea turbo snails, its not even funny. I have probably bought about 50 of them total, (at different tims of course) and they always do fine for a week or two, then die.... i dont know what it is. I always test after they die, and my nitrate, amonia, nitrite, phosphate, are all nearly undetectable, and my PH is normal. About 3 months ago, i got my last batch and after they died i just gave up. I think they have problems keeping on their right side whenever I find the empty shells, they are stuck in the sand upside down. Is there any kind of snail that will eat HA that can stay upright on its own?
 
Mexican turbos are the only snail that I know of that (may) eat hair algae. For general algae removal the Trochus Banded snails are good and can flip themselves. They will breed in an aquarium, so be ready for babies (I have hundreds that only come out at night).
 
Rainford's gobies eat hair algae, but you'll also need to do what others have said. They should also get along with sea horses.
 
ya know- in the past two days I went from a crystal clear tank to... some sort of algae bloom. ugh, looks like greenwater, ALMOST. not as bad, but ALMOST.

I cranked my skimmer up, and have the lights off... at least yours you can scrub off. mine will just reproduce more in the water if I change it... which will happen next week (I'm outta salt mix, OF COURSE when something like this happens!!!)
 
You mentioned that you are using RO/DI water. Have you tested the RO/DI water itself for phosphates? Your tests of the tank water could be misleading because the algae is using up the phosphate. Whatever the algae is feeding on has to be coming from some where and from your description i would check your makeup water.
I had a red slime and hair algae out break last summer in my 92 show tank because my RO/DI filters needed changing. It took 3-4 months of weekly water changes to finally get rid of the crap. I almost threw in the towel and said the heck with it because it was killing my corals and my tank looked like crap.
Hang in there.

Ken
 
No there are no phosphates in the Ro water my parents order it from some company, and they deliver it in big jugs to my house... I have tested it, and there are no phosphates or nitrates in it...
 
Wow i wonder how much money someone could make by mutating some sorta bacteria to eat only bad algea that are produced in aquariums, and selling it in bottles. lol
 
Not sure if this has been suggested , but I recently am fighting an algea bloom that began after I started adding Phytoplankton. I was adding too much and once algea started it was hard to stop. I since have stopped adding phyto altogether and through constant waterchanges, increasing flow, lots of phosban, and adding cheato in the tank I am winning the battle.
 
Back
Top