i got a question about live rock

chrisbahn2002

New member
So i been going to this pet store for a while and they are selling live rock at about 6$ a pound. here is the kicker, the live rock is dry and when i asked them about it they stated it is dehydrated and will come back to life when placed in the tank. is this a new thing or are they ripping folks off?
 
lol, well they aren't wrong. It will eventually come back to life. I wouldn't pay 6 dollars a pound for dry rock. Unless they were some awesome structures.
 
Well, I guess they're not necessarily lying.....It is dehydrated and it will come back to life, but it's current condition is not what is considered to be "Live" rock.

It is dry rock, so it will take cycling it to bring it back to life. :bigeyes:
 

its not packaged it is sitting on a shelf in the store exposed to air. the rock looks nice but a bit expensive if not already live i believe. this is in pollys pet shop in live oak, texas near San Antonio. maybe someone on here is near by and knows what i am talking about with this store. but yes it maybe if it is bare rock
 
I don't know about the 'Life" rock, never really bought into the spore thing. What I do know is that sitting on a shelf dry it is dead rock.
 
In Nov 2014 I started my first tank with Life Rock. The store recommended it but had no idea that there would be virtually no cycle. I kept testing and never saw spikes. Added a bit of fish food and after a few weeks of waiting I added two clownfish. At one point about 2 weeks later I saw a very small indicator of nitrite and after a water change it was gone. I still have those fish and all the fish that have lived in that tank. I was testing the water everyday to that point.

Not sure if this is everyone's experience with the product or not. I did wait a few weeks just in case because I didn't want to subject the fish to bad conditions.

I have an 80g now that has a mix of rock that was dry and rock that was live. I like the looks of that rock better.

At $6 a pound you can buy life rock cheaper online but it's always good to support a lfs. I'd compare the price online and if you go that route maybe negotiate with the store a bit to split the difference. It's good to build relationships with them but not taken over the coals.
 
It sounds like dry rock that is treated with bacteria. This would be close to the "live sand" people buy, but a different process of seeding it.

There are 2 diff sets of "life" on rock: bacteria, and relatively larger critters. For bacteria, there are many ways to get your population established, aka cycle the tank. Some like to go natural and wait for bacteria from the air, some add bottle of liquid to seed it, some buy live sand, you can buy this rock too. All of those methods have pros and cons.

For larger critters, they will not reanimate after death from dehydration. These are tyour sponges, crabs, snails, filter feeders, etc. Some people like to pay more for live rock that has these to jump start the biodiversity of the tank (not the cycle, though this sort of rock would have bacteria too so it's a 2 birds 1 stone thing), some prefer a finer-grained control over their inhabitants and thus chose dead rock to avoid bad hitchikers.

So it's personal preference. By way of comparison, tampa bay saltwater sells super live rock covered in critters and bacteria, shipped wet. It's basically a chunk of Walt Smith rock that's sat in the ocean. Idont think it's much more that $6 a pound after shipping. Reefcleaners has dead dry rock for $2 a pound free shipping. You can save some $ by using mostly dry with a few pieces of live as seed. If I was going to fill a tank with $6 a pound rock, I'd want some critters on it, otherwise I'd just get dry rock for $2 and a $4 bottle of biospira to seed the bacteria.
 
Back
Top