Ich Attack vs Kick Ich

[mling]

I am trying to decide between Ich Attach (claims to be organic) or Kick Ich to treat Ich in a hospital tank.

Does any one have any experience with them to advise on one verus the other.

Thanks in advance.

 

[Andrew]

Niether. Go with Hypo so you can 100% sure that all the ich present on the fish and in the QT tank is gone.

 

[LauraCline]

ich attack definately does not work. It turns out the active ingredient is just vitamin K. Nevertheless I tried for a week and the ich just got worse. It did turn the tank nice and brown though. The fish have been in copper for 12 days are are not symptomatic.