ID This Fish Please

[Maureensreef]

Is this a Pylei
I am having the same problem with an online company. They are telling me they sent a Pink Margin and I believe it to be a Pylei. They state they sent a Pink Margin and that is what the fish is. I sent the first picture to them and have since taken the second. I explained to them that the pelvic fins were too long for a Pink Margin and also noted the yellow above the eye. They said they contacted their Coral Farm for Id & Review. They have replied with the following - the customer order female/juvenile Pink Margin Fairy Wrasse and from the photo that is what she received.
We are happy to hear you have received the correct specimen.

So what do you think, is it a Pink Margin "Cirrhilabrus rubrimarginatus" or do you think it is a Pylei?

 

[saltnewb]

i think its a pink margin fairy , looks like the pics of em to me.

 

[evolved]

C. cf. pylei

 

[Maureensreef]

I have had several professionals look at the picture and it was determined to be a Pylei. Although the company stated that once they have their professionals make a decision they do not change their minds they said as a courtesy to me they would credit my account for the fish.