I've been in the hobby a while, and I've had older algae cleaning magnets go bad on me. Somehow saltwater breaches the outer casing and rusts the magnet inside, resulting in a bigger magnet that then ruptures the case. I now have 4 Magfloats and one Tunze that I have yet to have any problems with. With regard to impellers, I've had the same problem with one brand (which I shall not mention by name). Impellers have expanded and I've been unable to remove them from the pump to replace them.